The Book of Obligations and Pursuit in the Two Authentic Collections
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The book of obligations and pursuit based on the Two Authentic Collections, is it appropriate?
Answer : I do not think it is appropriate, because Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) responded to every criticism leveled against the Two Authentic Collections with two answers. The first answer is general, and the second is detailed. He said that the one who criticized the two Shaykhs, al-Bukhari and Muslim, in a general manner, the general answer is: You are a memorizer, and they are memorizers, and they are more scrupulous and more knowledgeable in the science of hadith than you. So if your statement conflicts with their statement, whose statement is to be accepted? Theirs, because they are closer to scrupulousness than you and more knowledgeable about hadith. So we have two conflicting statements, and this one is preferred. It is said: Now, your statement conflicts with theirs, and they are more noble, more scrupulous, and more knowledgeable than you, so your objection has no standing. This is the first answer. The second, detailed answer is that Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) pursued every criticism leveled against al-Bukhari and responded to it, and likewise al-Iraqi pursued the criticisms leveled against Muslim and responded to them, and some of them compiled a response to the criticisms leveled against both Muslim and al-Bukhari.
Answer : I do not think it is appropriate, because Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) responded to every criticism leveled against the Two Authentic Collections with two answers. The first answer is general, and the second is detailed. He said that the one who criticized the two Shaykhs, al-Bukhari and Muslim, in a general manner, the general answer is: You are a memorizer, and they are memorizers, and they are more scrupulous and more knowledgeable in the science of hadith than you. So if your statement conflicts with their statement, whose statement is to be accepted? Theirs, because they are closer to scrupulousness than you and more knowledgeable about hadith. So we have two conflicting statements, and this one is preferred. It is said: Now, your statement conflicts with theirs, and they are more noble, more scrupulous, and more knowledgeable than you, so your objection has no standing. This is the first answer. The second, detailed answer is that Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) pursued every criticism leveled against al-Bukhari and responded to it, and likewise al-Iraqi pursued the criticisms leveled against Muslim and responded to them, and some of them compiled a response to the criticisms leveled against both Muslim and al-Bukhari.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 67 - 70 كتاب الإلزامات والتتبع على الصحيحين - شرح البيقونية - الشيخ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
