Aspects of the Answer to the Hadith: "A people will not succeed if they place a woman in charge of their affairs"
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : I have to stay up late; the Maghrib prayer is in the morning.
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : In the hadith, is it not the saying of Abu Dharr and not a hadith?
The Shaykh : No, this is a hadith from the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) in al-Bukhari. When it was reported that the Persians placed the daughter of their king in charge, he saidJami` at-Tirmidhi 2262Sahih (Darussalam) and their women. Do you understand? And I have nothing more than this?
The questioner : I read it, meaning an idea.
The Shaykh : It affected you.
The questioner : I am early.
The Shaykh : In this suffering.
The questioner : What is the solution to this?
The Shaykh : In any case, the hadith is established in al-Bukhari, and I expected you to bring up to me that a people placed women in charge of their affairs and succeeded, like the English who always place a woman in charge of their affairs. Yes, and unfortunately, in Turkey now, the Prime Minister is a woman. Yes. It is said that the answer to this is:
From one of three aspects: either it is meant by his saying "A people will not succeed if they place a woman in charge of their affairs" that it refers only to those people, meaning the Persians, meaning that when they placed this woman in charge of their affairs, they will not succeed. And on this basis, it becomes specific, and if we make it specific, there is no problem.
The second aspect is that we say that these women did not take charge of the affairs in an absolute sense, do you understand? Rather, the one who manages the kingdom is other than them, but they have the title of leadership without the reality. The third aspect is that it is said that if these people had placed a man in charge, it would have been more successful for them. And the intended meaning of the negation "a people will not succeed" is the negation of complete success. It is said that if these people had placed a man in charge, it would have been more successful for them.
There is a fourth aspect that can be said: this, meaning the saying of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) "A people will not succeed," is based on the majority and the most common case. This is based on the majority and the most common case, and otherwise, they may succeed. So these are four aspects in answering this hadith, and Allah knows best.
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : In the hadith, is it not the saying of Abu Dharr and not a hadith?
The Shaykh : No, this is a hadith from the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) in al-Bukhari. When it was reported that the Persians placed the daughter of their king in charge, he said
A people will never succeed who give their
لن يفلح قوم ولوا أمرهمThe questioner : I read it, meaning an idea.
The Shaykh : It affected you.
The questioner : I am early.
The Shaykh : In this suffering.
The questioner : What is the solution to this?
The Shaykh : In any case, the hadith is established in al-Bukhari, and I expected you to bring up to me that a people placed women in charge of their affairs and succeeded, like the English who always place a woman in charge of their affairs. Yes, and unfortunately, in Turkey now, the Prime Minister is a woman. Yes. It is said that the answer to this is:
From one of three aspects: either it is meant by his saying "A people will not succeed if they place a woman in charge of their affairs" that it refers only to those people, meaning the Persians, meaning that when they placed this woman in charge of their affairs, they will not succeed. And on this basis, it becomes specific, and if we make it specific, there is no problem.
The second aspect is that we say that these women did not take charge of the affairs in an absolute sense, do you understand? Rather, the one who manages the kingdom is other than them, but they have the title of leadership without the reality. The third aspect is that it is said that if these people had placed a man in charge, it would have been more successful for them. And the intended meaning of the negation "a people will not succeed" is the negation of complete success. It is said that if these people had placed a man in charge, it would have been more successful for them.
There is a fourth aspect that can be said: this, meaning the saying of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) "A people will not succeed," is based on the majority and the most common case. This is based on the majority and the most common case, and otherwise, they may succeed. So these are four aspects in answering this hadith, and Allah knows best.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [818] هل يصح حديث: «لا يفلح قوم ولوا أمرهم امرأة»؟ وكيف نوفق بينه وبين إفلاح بعض النساء في الولاية؟
youtube.com
youtube.com
