What is the ruling on performing Hajj with stolen money?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Now, in this issue as well, if a person performs Hajj with stolen money, is his Hajj valid or not?
The Shaykh : Some scholars said that his Hajj is not valid, because money is a condition for the obligation. It is like a condition for validity, so it returns to being a condition for the act of worship. It was also said that the Hajj is valid but sinful, because money is not a condition for the obligation, just as it is not a condition for validity. The evidence that it is not a condition for the obligation is that the one who is near Makkah must perform Hajj even if he has no money, because he is able to perform Hajj on foot. However, it seems that Ibn Rajab (may Allah have mercy on him) looked into this and said, "This is of no value, for it is a condition only for the one who is far away, just as a mahram is a condition for the obligation. But for whom? For the woman. So it seems Ibn Rajab objected to Ibn Aqil in this distinction and said that it is a condition for the obligation. There is no objection to it being a condition for the obligation for some people and not for others, just as a mahram is a condition for the obligation for women, and yet it is a condition for women and not for men. But what appears to me is that Hajj with stolen money is valid, but it is forbidden.
Because Hajj does not depend on money. As Ibn Aqil said, a person may perform Hajj without money. Even if he is far away, he may perform Hajj without money. He can perform Hajj on foot with the caravan. This happened often in previous times. People would come from distant lands for Hajj. They would come from Pakistan and from India on their feet. Yes, indeed.
The questioner : From the general shirk, may Allah be Exalted. Is the general shirk not recorded?
The Shaykh : If your Hajj depends on money, then the presence of money is necessary, but it is not obligatory. A person may perform Hajj and not have money. The revelation of the verse and marriage indicate the existence of the financial aspect. No, it does not indicate existence. It indicates that it is better for a person to marry so that he becomes a means for others. If a person has, for example, his usual provisions for eating in his country, or what provides that, then there is no money in excess of the original amount.
The Shaykh : Some scholars said that his Hajj is not valid, because money is a condition for the obligation. It is like a condition for validity, so it returns to being a condition for the act of worship. It was also said that the Hajj is valid but sinful, because money is not a condition for the obligation, just as it is not a condition for validity. The evidence that it is not a condition for the obligation is that the one who is near Makkah must perform Hajj even if he has no money, because he is able to perform Hajj on foot. However, it seems that Ibn Rajab (may Allah have mercy on him) looked into this and said, "This is of no value, for it is a condition only for the one who is far away, just as a mahram is a condition for the obligation. But for whom? For the woman. So it seems Ibn Rajab objected to Ibn Aqil in this distinction and said that it is a condition for the obligation. There is no objection to it being a condition for the obligation for some people and not for others, just as a mahram is a condition for the obligation for women, and yet it is a condition for women and not for men. But what appears to me is that Hajj with stolen money is valid, but it is forbidden.
Because Hajj does not depend on money. As Ibn Aqil said, a person may perform Hajj without money. Even if he is far away, he may perform Hajj without money. He can perform Hajj on foot with the caravan. This happened often in previous times. People would come from distant lands for Hajj. They would come from Pakistan and from India on their feet. Yes, indeed.
The questioner : From the general shirk, may Allah be Exalted. Is the general shirk not recorded?
The Shaykh : If your Hajj depends on money, then the presence of money is necessary, but it is not obligatory. A person may perform Hajj and not have money. The revelation of the verse and marriage indicate the existence of the financial aspect. No, it does not indicate existence. It indicates that it is better for a person to marry so that he becomes a means for others. If a person has, for example, his usual provisions for eating in his country, or what provides that, then there is no money in excess of the original amount.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 121 -ما حكم الحج بالمال المغصوب؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
