Prohibition of Saying, “O Allah, forgive me if You will”
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner says: In the chapter on tawhid (the oneness of Allah), it is stated that one should not say, “O Allah, forgive me if You will,” as this is prohibited. Rather, one should be decisive in the matter and supplicate to the Lord. How do we reconcile this ruling with our saying, for example, “I will fast tomorrow, if Allah wills”?
Answer : In the first case, “O Allah, forgive me if You will,” the action of Allah is made conditional upon His will. In the second case, “I will fast tomorrow, if Allah wills,” one’s own action is made conditional upon His will. Therefore, there is no agreement between the two. As for matters that are attributed to Allah and are beloved to Him, when you ask Allah for them, you should not make them conditional upon His will, for there is no need for that. Does Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, need to be compelled to give you what you asked for until you say, “If You will, give it to me, or not”?
Does Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, find what you asked Him for difficult, or consider it great, such that it burdens Him, and He hesitates about whether to give it to you or not, until you say, “If You will”? None of this is the case. For this reason, the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) explained the reason for the prohibition in his saying: “Let none of you say, ‘O Allah, forgive me if You will; O Allah, have mercy on me if You will.’”
He explained this with two reasons. He said, “Indeed, Allah is not compelled by anyone.” And he said, “Indeed, nothing is too great for Allah to give.” Then, there is also a second or third reason. It is that when a person says, “O Allah, forgive me if You will,”
it is as if he is in no need of it. That is, he is saying, “If You will, give it; if You will, do not give it; I do not care.” This undoubtedly indicates that the supplicant is praying while considering himself independent of Allah, Mighty and Majestic. All these reasons indicate that it is forbidden for a person to say, “O Allah, forgive me if You will; O Allah, have mercy on me if You will.” However, let us all examine the saying of the one who says, “May Allah have mercy on so-and-so, if Allah wills,” or says, “May Allah make your ending good, if Allah wills,” or similar matters that are beloved. If one says “if Allah wills” in such cases, is it like saying “O Allah, forgive me if You will,” and thus forbidden? Because the saying “May Allah forgive him, if Allah wills” and the like is common on the tongues of many people. Many people, when they supplicate, say “if Allah wills.” Do we say that it is like the saying of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), “if You will,” and that it is forbidden? Or do we say that the intention behind it is seeking blessing (tabarruk) rather than making it conditional? It is my opinion that those who say it intend to seek blessing. However, with this, it is not appropriate for them to say it. Rather, they should say, “May Allah forgive him,” and not say “if Allah wills,” because this is a supplication. And if it is a supplication, a person should be decisive in the matter and not make it conditional upon the will. As for the saying of the one who says, “I will fast tomorrow, if Allah wills,” his intention is seeking blessing. And he has only made the matter conditional upon something he himself will do, not upon something Allah will do. Thus, it becomes clear that there is a clear difference between the two matters.
Answer : In the first case, “O Allah, forgive me if You will,” the action of Allah is made conditional upon His will. In the second case, “I will fast tomorrow, if Allah wills,” one’s own action is made conditional upon His will. Therefore, there is no agreement between the two. As for matters that are attributed to Allah and are beloved to Him, when you ask Allah for them, you should not make them conditional upon His will, for there is no need for that. Does Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, need to be compelled to give you what you asked for until you say, “If You will, give it to me, or not”?
Does Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, find what you asked Him for difficult, or consider it great, such that it burdens Him, and He hesitates about whether to give it to you or not, until you say, “If You will”? None of this is the case. For this reason, the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) explained the reason for the prohibition in his saying: “Let none of you say, ‘O Allah, forgive me if You will; O Allah, have mercy on me if You will.’”
He explained this with two reasons. He said, “Indeed, Allah is not compelled by anyone.” And he said, “Indeed, nothing is too great for Allah to give.” Then, there is also a second or third reason. It is that when a person says, “O Allah, forgive me if You will,”
it is as if he is in no need of it. That is, he is saying, “If You will, give it; if You will, do not give it; I do not care.” This undoubtedly indicates that the supplicant is praying while considering himself independent of Allah, Mighty and Majestic. All these reasons indicate that it is forbidden for a person to say, “O Allah, forgive me if You will; O Allah, have mercy on me if You will.” However, let us all examine the saying of the one who says, “May Allah have mercy on so-and-so, if Allah wills,” or says, “May Allah make your ending good, if Allah wills,” or similar matters that are beloved. If one says “if Allah wills” in such cases, is it like saying “O Allah, forgive me if You will,” and thus forbidden? Because the saying “May Allah forgive him, if Allah wills” and the like is common on the tongues of many people. Many people, when they supplicate, say “if Allah wills.” Do we say that it is like the saying of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), “if You will,” and that it is forbidden? Or do we say that the intention behind it is seeking blessing (tabarruk) rather than making it conditional? It is my opinion that those who say it intend to seek blessing. However, with this, it is not appropriate for them to say it. Rather, they should say, “May Allah forgive him,” and not say “if Allah wills,” because this is a supplication. And if it is a supplication, a person should be decisive in the matter and not make it conditional upon the will. As for the saying of the one who says, “I will fast tomorrow, if Allah wills,” his intention is seeking blessing. And he has only made the matter conditional upon something he himself will do, not upon something Allah will do. Thus, it becomes clear that there is a clear difference between the two matters.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[45 من 50] النهي عن قولنا اللهم اغفر لي إن شئت - الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
