The ruling on doubt regarding the omission of an obligatory act in prayer
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : If one doubts whether he omitted an obligatory act. Doubt about omitting an obligatory act, not omitting something else.
The Shaykh : Yes. For example, he stood up for the third rak'ah and doubted whether he sat for the first tashahhud and performed it or not. So what does he do? The details of the Sunnah.
Yes? No, meaning whether the doubt is one where one possibility is stronger or not, let us proceed with a scenario where both opinions agree. He doubted, and in his doubt, nothing was stronger, yes. So some scholars said that sujud al-sahw is obligatory upon him.
Because the default is that he did not perform it. So when this man stood up for the third rak'ah, he said, "By Allah, it appears I did not sit in the first prostration." We say: You must prostrate. Why? Because the default is that you did not sit, and you have no certainty.
And some scholars said there is no sujud upon him, no sujud upon him. Why is there no sujud upon him? He said, yes, because he is in doubt about the cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory. What is the cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory?
The cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory is the omission of the tashahhud. This is the omission of the tashahhud, and now he is in doubt whether he omitted the tashahhud or not. So he is in doubt about the cause, and the default is the non-existence of the cause that necessitates the prostration. Based on this, there is no sujud upon him. See how the scholars (may Allah have mercy on them) derived this.
The Shaykh : Yes. For example, he stood up for the third rak'ah and doubted whether he sat for the first tashahhud and performed it or not. So what does he do? The details of the Sunnah.
Yes? No, meaning whether the doubt is one where one possibility is stronger or not, let us proceed with a scenario where both opinions agree. He doubted, and in his doubt, nothing was stronger, yes. So some scholars said that sujud al-sahw is obligatory upon him.
Because the default is that he did not perform it. So when this man stood up for the third rak'ah, he said, "By Allah, it appears I did not sit in the first prostration." We say: You must prostrate. Why? Because the default is that you did not sit, and you have no certainty.
And some scholars said there is no sujud upon him, no sujud upon him. Why is there no sujud upon him? He said, yes, because he is in doubt about the cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory. What is the cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory?
The cause that makes sujud al-sahw obligatory is the omission of the tashahhud. This is the omission of the tashahhud, and now he is in doubt whether he omitted the tashahhud or not. So he is in doubt about the cause, and the default is the non-existence of the cause that necessitates the prostration. Based on this, there is no sujud upon him. See how the scholars (may Allah have mercy on them) derived this.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2178حكم الشك في ترك واجب في الصلاة📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
