What is the ruling if a man enters the prayer while the imam is bowing and he says Allahu Akbar only once?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If he arrives while the imam is bowing, he says Allahu Akbar now. Does he also need the takbir of bowing? The takbir of bowing is dropped for the one who is standing according to Ahmad, or according to the report from Ahmad. But does he have to intend, is it a condition that he intend with this takbir that it is the takbir of opening, which is the takbir of entering the state of ihram, or is it sufficient for him to intend that it is just a takbir?
Answer : Yes, there is also a report from him. The report that it is necessary for him to intend that it is the takbir of entering the state of ihram, because two takbirs have come together for us in this place, so he needs to distinguish one of them by intention. The second opinion, or the second report, says that it is sufficient for him to intend the absolute takbir without specifying it as the takbir of entering the state of ihram. They analogized this to the one who arrives while the imam is standing and says the takbir of prayer; is it a condition for him to intend the takbir of entering the state of ihram or not? It is said that it is not a condition for him to intend the takbir of entering the state of ihram. This issue is either that he intends it to be the takbir of entering the state of ihram, or he intends it to be the takbir of bowing, or he is negligent regarding this and that, intending neither the takbir of entering the state of ihram nor the takbir of bowing. If he intends the takbir of entering the state of ihram, it suffices for him. If he intends it for bowing, it does not suffice for him. If he is negligent, then according to the stronger opinion, it suffices for him. Yes. Do you not need to? No. The intention of entering is sufficient, and this man said the takbir for entering the prayer.
Answer : Yes, there is also a report from him. The report that it is necessary for him to intend that it is the takbir of entering the state of ihram, because two takbirs have come together for us in this place, so he needs to distinguish one of them by intention. The second opinion, or the second report, says that it is sufficient for him to intend the absolute takbir without specifying it as the takbir of entering the state of ihram. They analogized this to the one who arrives while the imam is standing and says the takbir of prayer; is it a condition for him to intend the takbir of entering the state of ihram or not? It is said that it is not a condition for him to intend the takbir of entering the state of ihram. This issue is either that he intends it to be the takbir of entering the state of ihram, or he intends it to be the takbir of bowing, or he is negligent regarding this and that, intending neither the takbir of entering the state of ihram nor the takbir of bowing. If he intends the takbir of entering the state of ihram, it suffices for him. If he intends it for bowing, it does not suffice for him. If he is negligent, then according to the stronger opinion, it suffices for him. Yes. Do you not need to? No. The intention of entering is sufficient, and this man said the takbir for entering the prayer.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 205 - ما الحكم إذا دخل رجل في الصلاة والإمام راكع وكبّر تكبيرة واحدة؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
