Refutation of the Doctrine of Indwelling
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Honorable Shaykh! What is the meaning of the hadith: "If you were to lower a rope to the seventh earth, it would reach Allah"? And how do you respond to those who say that it indicates indwelling?
Answer : Yes, regarding this hadith, first, the scholars differed on its authenticity. Some said it is a weak hadith that cannot serve as a proof, while those who deemed it authentic said that its meaning is that Allah the Exalted encompasses everything.
If a person were to lower a rope from the earth he is on, it would reach Allah, because Allah the Exalted encompasses everything. No matter where you are on the earth, the sky is above you, and Allah is above what? The sky. So, if a person were to lower a rope to the lower earth, it would reach Allah, meaning it would end with Allah (Glorified and Exalted is He), because Allah is above everything. The earth, in relation to the Footstool and the Throne, is nothing; it is like a ring cast into a vast expanse of land. As for the response to those who claim indwelling based on this hadith, we say that indwelling contradicts the perfection of Allah and opposes what the Salaf agreed upon regarding the elevation of Allah by His essence. Therefore, it is impossible that the hadith mentioned by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), or reported about him, would contradict what the Qur'an indicates and what the Muslims have agreed upon.
Answer : Yes, regarding this hadith, first, the scholars differed on its authenticity. Some said it is a weak hadith that cannot serve as a proof, while those who deemed it authentic said that its meaning is that Allah the Exalted encompasses everything.
If a person were to lower a rope from the earth he is on, it would reach Allah, because Allah the Exalted encompasses everything. No matter where you are on the earth, the sky is above you, and Allah is above what? The sky. So, if a person were to lower a rope to the lower earth, it would reach Allah, meaning it would end with Allah (Glorified and Exalted is He), because Allah is above everything. The earth, in relation to the Footstool and the Throne, is nothing; it is like a ring cast into a vast expanse of land. As for the response to those who claim indwelling based on this hadith, we say that indwelling contradicts the perfection of Allah and opposes what the Salaf agreed upon regarding the elevation of Allah by His essence. Therefore, it is impossible that the hadith mentioned by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), or reported about him, would contradict what the Qur'an indicates and what the Muslims have agreed upon.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[51 من 216] الرد على عقيدة الحلول - الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
