Text copied Link copied

Al-Fatawa – home

﴿ فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

Scholar
Search mode

A man joined the imam in the second rak'ah, and the imam made a mistake and prayed five. Is this extra rak'ah counted for him?

Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : A man joined the imam in the second rak'ah, and the imam made a mistake and prayed five. Is this extra rak'ah counted for this latecomer?

The Shaykh : This extra rak'ah. We say, "Salam with the imam," or we say, "When the imam says the salam, complete the rak'ah you missed from the beginning of the prayer." Yes, you say he says the salam to both. So, the one who disagrees comes for the fourth. You differed on two opinions, just as the scholars differed on two opinions.
Some scholars say that it is obligatory for this latecomer, who missed one rak'ah, that when the imam prays the fifth, he must come for a rak'ah. What is the evidence? They said: Because the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said
and pray whatever you get (with the people) and complete the rest which you have missedما أدركتم فصلوا وما فاتكم فأتموا
Sahih al-Bukhari 635
and this one missed a rak'ah, so he missed a rak'ah, and he must complete it. Others said it is not permissible to come for a rak'ah. This latecomer who prayed four with the imam is not permitted to come for a rak'ah, because if he came for a rak'ah, he would have intentionally prayed five. The imam is excused because he was negligent, but what permits you to come for a fifth rak'ah? This is the correct opinion.
That it is counted for him with this rak'ah, and he does not come for anything else. But what is the answer to the hadith these people cited?
and pray whatever you get (with the people) and complete the rest which you have missedما أدركتم فصلوا وما فاتكم فأتموا
Sahih al-Bukhari 635
We say this hadith is an argument against you. Yes.
And it is not for you, because the saying of the Messenger, "Complete what you missed," indicates that the imam said the salam before the completion of the prayer of the one who was sleeping, so he completed it. If it was completed with four, then there is nothing left for me to complete. For this reason, the hadith, for whoever reflects on it, is evidence for the one who says he says the salam with the imam, and evidence against the one who says he must come for a rak'ah. Is that clear, everyone? He must prostrate now, prostrate now following his imam. Yes.
The imam, yes, perhaps he does not prostrate until after the salam. Perhaps he does not strike for the excess until after the salam as well. We say, prostrate, because the excess now, what is it? He caught the last one, and this latecomer who was following has caught it, so he is one who caught the error of his imam. Yes.
Source قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 36 - 37 رجل دخل مع الإمام فر الركعة الثانية وسهى الإمام وصلى خمسة فهل يعتد له بهذه الركعة الزائدة؟
youtube.com
Flag this fatwa