The operative cause for not pointing to the Black Stone at the beginning of the Sa'y when touching the Stone is difficult—Comments on al-Kafi
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : After the two rak'ahs of the tawaf, the sunnah is to touch the Stone. If touching it is difficult, what is the evidence, given that the first touching in the tawaf involves pointing when touching is difficult?
The Shaykh : Because the first touching is more emphasized, and for this reason, kissing it was prescribed, whereas this is not the case. It is similar to touching the Yemeni Corner, where one points to indicate the touching, but due to the crowding, one does not point to it.
The questioner : In the tawaf, if touching is difficult, one points, which indicates that pointing serves as a substitute for touching at the beginning.
The Shaykh : Yes, but is there a report that one points to the Yemeni Corner? There is no report. We say that touching during the tawaf is more emphasized than this touching, and for this reason, kissing it was prescribed, whereas this was not prescribed.
The Shaykh : Because the first touching is more emphasized, and for this reason, kissing it was prescribed, whereas this is not the case. It is similar to touching the Yemeni Corner, where one points to indicate the touching, but due to the crowding, one does not point to it.
The questioner : In the tawaf, if touching is difficult, one points, which indicates that pointing serves as a substitute for touching at the beginning.
The Shaykh : Yes, but is there a report that one points to the Yemeni Corner? There is no report. We say that touching during the tawaf is more emphasized than this touching, and for this reason, kissing it was prescribed, whereas this was not prescribed.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [3371] العلة في ترك الإشارة إلى الحجر الأسود في بداية السعي عند تعذر استلام الحجر-تعليقات على الكافي
youtube.com
youtube.com
