If one’s crop is watered sometimes with expense and sometimes without: What is the amount of obligatory zakah?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Yes, this is a question. He says: If this crop was watered with expense at first, and then it started in the region to mix, and the rain stopped, how do we explain it? Do we say this is watered with expense or watered without expense?
Answer : We say that it is obligatory for us to look at it with justice. If half of the time is with expense and half without expense, what is obligatory for him? Three-quarters of one-tenth, three-quarters of one-tenth. That is, if this man has a pump, and the duration of his watering is six months, the first three months he waters it with expense using a machine, and after that the rains came and he stopped, and he will drink by what means? By the means of rain. Half the time with expense and half the time without expense. For a man like this, three-quarters of one-tenth is obligatory for him, three-quarters of one-tenth, considering this and that. Yes, by this and that. Is that clear, everyone? And this may happen frequently in some countries. You find that people, as soon as they start, have two hundred [units] in the rain, so they need a roof. Here, instead of it coming down in abundance, they do not stop.
Answer : We say that it is obligatory for us to look at it with justice. If half of the time is with expense and half without expense, what is obligatory for him? Three-quarters of one-tenth, three-quarters of one-tenth. That is, if this man has a pump, and the duration of his watering is six months, the first three months he waters it with expense using a machine, and after that the rains came and he stopped, and he will drink by what means? By the means of rain. Half the time with expense and half the time without expense. For a man like this, three-quarters of one-tenth is obligatory for him, three-quarters of one-tenth, considering this and that. Yes, by this and that. Is that clear, everyone? And this may happen frequently in some countries. You find that people, as soon as they start, have two hundred [units] in the rain, so they need a roof. Here, instead of it coming down in abundance, they do not stop.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 424- من سُقي زرعه تارة بمؤونة وأخرى بغيرها: كم مقدار الزكاة الواجبة؟ II ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
