Seeking Judgment from a Judge Who Does Not Rule by What Allah Has Revealed
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : May Allah bless you. Is it permissible for me to seek judgment from a judge who rules by other than what Allah has revealed in a matter where I know the truth is with me? Is it permissible to seek judgment with this person before a judge who rules by other than what Allah has revealed? Or is this a form of dealing in sin and transgression?
The Shaykh : Ibn al-Qayyim mentioned this issue at the beginning of *Al-Turuq al-Hukmiyyah* and said: If we prevented people from seeking judgment from these judges, people's rights would be lost. Where would this man seek judgment? If there are only judges in the lands who rule by laws, rights would be lost. So, if you know that the truth is with you and that if you seek judgment from this man, he will rule with the truth that is with you, there is no harm. This is because the sin in seeking judgment from other than Allah, or other than what rules by the Book and the Sunnah, is to contradict the truth. So, if it aligns with the truth, there is no harm. For this reason, 'Umar said to the one who was not satisfied with the ruling of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him): "Is this how it is?"
He said, "Yes." So he struck him and killed him. So, if you know that the truth is with you and that these judges will rule in your favor with the truth, there is no harm. And this is found now in many Islamic countries, where judges rule by laws. So, if I have a right and I know it is a right, do I leave it just because they rule by laws? That is a problem.
The questioner : And if he will rule, meaning, by other than [the truth].
The Shaykh : No. If you know that this man takes bribes and that I will bribe him and he will rule in my favor, and I know that I am not in the right, this is forbidden, and there is no doubt about it.
The Shaykh : Ibn al-Qayyim mentioned this issue at the beginning of *Al-Turuq al-Hukmiyyah* and said: If we prevented people from seeking judgment from these judges, people's rights would be lost. Where would this man seek judgment? If there are only judges in the lands who rule by laws, rights would be lost. So, if you know that the truth is with you and that if you seek judgment from this man, he will rule with the truth that is with you, there is no harm. This is because the sin in seeking judgment from other than Allah, or other than what rules by the Book and the Sunnah, is to contradict the truth. So, if it aligns with the truth, there is no harm. For this reason, 'Umar said to the one who was not satisfied with the ruling of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him): "Is this how it is?"
He said, "Yes." So he struck him and killed him. So, if you know that the truth is with you and that these judges will rule in your favor with the truth, there is no harm. And this is found now in many Islamic countries, where judges rule by laws. So, if I have a right and I know it is a right, do I leave it just because they rule by laws? That is a problem.
The questioner : And if he will rule, meaning, by other than [the truth].
The Shaykh : No. If you know that this man takes bribes and that I will bribe him and he will rule in my favor, and I know that I am not in the right, this is forbidden, and there is no doubt about it.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2134 - التحاكم إلى قاضي لا يحكم بما أنزل الله - الكافي في فقه الإمام أحمد بن حنبل - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
