The ruling on taking a person who has erred to a scholar by force
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Or he says to a person that he has erred, or he thinks he has erred, and he takes him to a scholar to adjudicate between them.
The Shaykh : If it is like 'Umar, there is no harm. No, it does not apply to the layperson. I do not think it was yesterday; the best thing is to hold his hand gently and say, "Please, let us ask so-and-so the scholar." But if he leads him now, he is taking him by treachery and leading him further, or overpowering him. Let him go, yes.
No, we do not see this at all. In truth, times differ, men differ, and circumstances differ. He is accountable to the people of hisbah (market inspectors), for example.
By Allah, look at the situation. The people of hisbah are deputies for the one in authority. So they do not exceed what they were directed to do. If they are told to do so-and-so, they do it; if they are told not to do so-and-so, they do not do it. For this reason, the scholars said in the book of judgment that it is not permissible for the judge to exceed what he was authorized to do, whether in wording or by custom.
The Shaykh : If it is like 'Umar, there is no harm. No, it does not apply to the layperson. I do not think it was yesterday; the best thing is to hold his hand gently and say, "Please, let us ask so-and-so the scholar." But if he leads him now, he is taking him by treachery and leading him further, or overpowering him. Let him go, yes.
No, we do not see this at all. In truth, times differ, men differ, and circumstances differ. He is accountable to the people of hisbah (market inspectors), for example.
By Allah, look at the situation. The people of hisbah are deputies for the one in authority. So they do not exceed what they were directed to do. If they are told to do so-and-so, they do it; if they are told not to do so-and-so, they do not do it. For this reason, the scholars said in the book of judgment that it is not permissible for the judge to exceed what he was authorized to do, whether in wording or by custom.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1825 - 4600 هل يجوز للرجل أو لأهل الحسبة إذا رأو من أخطأ أن يؤتى بالمخطئ يقاد كما فعل...؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
