The ruling on placing something in the place of prayer when standing up
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If he looks at the place he knows, is he required to place a marker?
Answer : If he places something, that is safer, because in our current custom, one who stands up for a reason must place something. If he does not place something, and then a person comes and moves to that place, and the first person returns, a dispute arises between them. The apparent meaning of the hadith is that Shaykh Ahmad is more entitled to it, but based on our current custom, one who stands up places something to prevent the dispute. Because, for example, a layperson finds his place and sits in it, then his companion comes and says, "I went to the toilet to perform wudu and I will return," and the other says, "Right away," and he did not put anything down. Or perhaps he does not believe him, and then he says, "It is established that this place is yours." Then he asks those around him to testify, and they say, "By Allah, we were unaware; we do not know if it is you or someone else." Then the matter reaches the court, and this is a problem.
Answer : If he places something, that is safer, because in our current custom, one who stands up for a reason must place something. If he does not place something, and then a person comes and moves to that place, and the first person returns, a dispute arises between them. The apparent meaning of the hadith is that Shaykh Ahmad is more entitled to it, but based on our current custom, one who stands up places something to prevent the dispute. Because, for example, a layperson finds his place and sits in it, then his companion comes and says, "I went to the toilet to perform wudu and I will return," and the other says, "Right away," and he did not put anything down. Or perhaps he does not believe him, and then he says, "It is established that this place is yours." Then he asks those around him to testify, and they say, "By Allah, we were unaware; we do not know if it is you or someone else." Then the matter reaches the court, and this is a problem.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 4896قام من مكانه في المسجد لعارض هل يجب عليه أن يضع...📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
