The continuity between the circuits of sa'y is a condition
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : I am ready for the comments.
The Shaykh : Yes, but if he leaves it and then remembers it shortly after, he should complete it. This is why the fifth condition is continuity between them,
The presenter : If Allah wills.
The Shaykh : between the circuits, meaning that it is necessary for him to sa'y until he completes it. So if he sa'yed three circuits and then went to his house to eat and sleep, and then came back and completed the remaining four, is that permissible or not?
The presenter : Amen.
The Shaykh : What if, for example, it was difficult for one person to come and complete the circuits because the people were very crowded and there was pushing among them in the late afternoon, so he delayed the remaining four circuits until the end of the day? Is that permissible or not?
It is not permissible, because continuity is a condition. The evidence that it is a condition is that sa'y is a single act of worship, and if the parts of a single act of worship are not continuous, it is no longer a single act of worship; it becomes a fragmented act of worship. Therefore, continuity is necessary. Some scholars said that continuity between the circuits of sa'y is not a condition, but rather a recommended practice, meaning that if he separates them, there is no harm. According to their opinion, if he performed one circuit on a Monday morning, one circuit on a Tuesday, one circuit on a Wednesday, one circuit on a Thursday, one circuit on a Friday, and one circuit on a Saturday, is that valid? This is not valid. Who says that this man is in the hour between al-Safa and the arrangement of the circuits? Never. Yes, for this reason, the correct view is that continuity between the circuits is a condition. However, if the interval is short due to a need or an excuse, there is no harm. For example, if some people are tired from sa'y, it is fine for him to sit and rest, then resume from where he left off on the path; he resumes from where he left off. Likewise, if he was pushed by the crowd or left, and went to relieve himself, there is no harm if he returns to complete it, because we distinguish between what is necessitated by dire necessity and what is not necessitated. Based on this, we say that continuity between the circuits is a condition, but if he fails to maintain it due to an excuse and resumes immediately when the excuse is removed, then it is valid and there is no blame on him.
The Shaykh : Yes, but if he leaves it and then remembers it shortly after, he should complete it. This is why the fifth condition is continuity between them,
The presenter : If Allah wills.
The Shaykh : between the circuits, meaning that it is necessary for him to sa'y until he completes it. So if he sa'yed three circuits and then went to his house to eat and sleep, and then came back and completed the remaining four, is that permissible or not?
The presenter : Amen.
The Shaykh : What if, for example, it was difficult for one person to come and complete the circuits because the people were very crowded and there was pushing among them in the late afternoon, so he delayed the remaining four circuits until the end of the day? Is that permissible or not?
It is not permissible, because continuity is a condition. The evidence that it is a condition is that sa'y is a single act of worship, and if the parts of a single act of worship are not continuous, it is no longer a single act of worship; it becomes a fragmented act of worship. Therefore, continuity is necessary. Some scholars said that continuity between the circuits of sa'y is not a condition, but rather a recommended practice, meaning that if he separates them, there is no harm. According to their opinion, if he performed one circuit on a Monday morning, one circuit on a Tuesday, one circuit on a Wednesday, one circuit on a Thursday, one circuit on a Friday, and one circuit on a Saturday, is that valid? This is not valid. Who says that this man is in the hour between al-Safa and the arrangement of the circuits? Never. Yes, for this reason, the correct view is that continuity between the circuits is a condition. However, if the interval is short due to a need or an excuse, there is no harm. For example, if some people are tired from sa'y, it is fine for him to sit and rest, then resume from where he left off on the path; he resumes from where he left off. Likewise, if he was pushed by the crowd or left, and went to relieve himself, there is no harm if he returns to complete it, because we distinguish between what is necessitated by dire necessity and what is not necessitated. Based on this, we say that continuity between the circuits is a condition, but if he fails to maintain it due to an excuse and resumes immediately when the excuse is removed, then it is valid and there is no blame on him.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 603- يُشترط الموالاة بين أشواط السعي. II فوائد من الدروس الفقهية من المحاضرات الجامعية لابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
