Distinguishing between the takbirs in the prayer
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh. The people are large in number relative to what is happening regarding knowledge. Moving from the prostration to the first tashahhud makes his takbirs equal to the takbirs of what he extends, and he narrates the matters. First, many people find this difficult, and they stand up, then return to the imam who is sitting. If some of the congregation recognize this and know it, and people come, for example, on the road, and people come, for example, they see us as if we are in a state of ihram or something like that, so they warn them about this gathering.
The Shaykh : Has the distinction between the takbirs been mentioned in the Sunnah? What do you have? What do you have? No, I have not found it. I researched it myself, and I asked the brothers, like Hamad al-Ansari (may Allah have mercy on him), who have knowledge of hadith, to look into it. They did not find a chapter for it. Then, if you distinguish, the ma'mum becomes a machine that is moved; you press this button and it works, you stop and it stops, because he will follow what?
The questioner : When you are.
The Shaykh : The imam is in this takbir. Yes, so he loses his presence. But if you let the ma'mum say his own takbir, and he fears that he will stand up while the people are sitting, he will fail, he will get it right once, so there is a benefit for the ma'mum. It is true that the one who entered with you, for example, in the second rak'ah, does not know that you stood up or sat down for the tashahhud.
The questioner : He reads the standing with him.
The Shaykh : Who is Khalid who came? He wants to explain it to him.
The questioner : All his work and action.
The Shaykh : By Allah, I do not like to do it. I used to do this. When I sat for the tashahhud, I said the takbir, and when I stood up, I said the takbir. But some of the nobles pointed it out to me. I said, "My brother, where did you get this from? Do you not want the Sunnah?" He said, "By Allah, we do not want the Sunnah, may Allah prevent it from them." He said, "Bring me a letter, I am its messenger." Okay, it was not mentioned. The first time I did it, people started saying, "Subhan Allah, Subhan Allah," thinking I had made a mistake. But they took it upon themselves, and praise be to Allah, things went well. Are you the imam? What do you do?
The questioner : I do not have control. Praise be to Allah.
The Shaykh : May Allah cut it out of you.
The questioner : You are, if Allah wills.
The Shaykh : The brevity of the Sunnah.
The questioner : Perhaps there are many problems; many people know about it.
The Shaykh : What matters to you? What is your name? Salih? No, Ibrahim, it does not matter to anyone. You follow the Sunnah and the people are sitting and following him.
The questioner : I love it, if Allah wills.
The Shaykh : Did you not know that sujud al-sahw after the salam was not known to the people? And a man I trust told me, and he is now in a high position, that he read a treatise. We used to write a treatise on sujud al-sahw in the past. He said he read it to the people, and they criticized it greatly. What is this new religion? What is in it? Is it complete? He said, "It is better for me to read to you a hadith, the hadith of Abu Hurayrah." He said, "No, we have not known this from our forefathers." You have in you what you do not have. He said, "Okay, we are waiting." That was the days when Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim was the head of the scholars, then Shaykh Ibn Ahmad after him, then Shaykh Ibn Baz the third. He was waiting for him. He had Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim, Shaykh from the gate, the Shaykh did not go out, it is fine. The Shaykh said yes. Shaykh Ibrahim ibn Hamir ibn Bazir said, "We want Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim." And the Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him) used to sit with the people after Maghrib between two meals. They made an appointment and went to the Shaykh and said, "O long-lived one, this new thing has come: it says to prostrate for forgetfulness after the salam." The Shaykh said, "Okay, he brought you a hadith." They said, "He said to us, 'By Allah, we are not common people, but we have not known this.'" He said, "No, the correct opinion is with him. And now, praise be to Allah, most of the imams apply the Sunnah in this, and the people took it upon themselves. Even the common people now know when the prostration is after the salam and when it is before the prostration. Did you understand?
The Shaykh : Has the distinction between the takbirs been mentioned in the Sunnah? What do you have? What do you have? No, I have not found it. I researched it myself, and I asked the brothers, like Hamad al-Ansari (may Allah have mercy on him), who have knowledge of hadith, to look into it. They did not find a chapter for it. Then, if you distinguish, the ma'mum becomes a machine that is moved; you press this button and it works, you stop and it stops, because he will follow what?
The questioner : When you are.
The Shaykh : The imam is in this takbir. Yes, so he loses his presence. But if you let the ma'mum say his own takbir, and he fears that he will stand up while the people are sitting, he will fail, he will get it right once, so there is a benefit for the ma'mum. It is true that the one who entered with you, for example, in the second rak'ah, does not know that you stood up or sat down for the tashahhud.
The questioner : He reads the standing with him.
The Shaykh : Who is Khalid who came? He wants to explain it to him.
The questioner : All his work and action.
The Shaykh : By Allah, I do not like to do it. I used to do this. When I sat for the tashahhud, I said the takbir, and when I stood up, I said the takbir. But some of the nobles pointed it out to me. I said, "My brother, where did you get this from? Do you not want the Sunnah?" He said, "By Allah, we do not want the Sunnah, may Allah prevent it from them." He said, "Bring me a letter, I am its messenger." Okay, it was not mentioned. The first time I did it, people started saying, "Subhan Allah, Subhan Allah," thinking I had made a mistake. But they took it upon themselves, and praise be to Allah, things went well. Are you the imam? What do you do?
The questioner : I do not have control. Praise be to Allah.
The Shaykh : May Allah cut it out of you.
The questioner : You are, if Allah wills.
The Shaykh : The brevity of the Sunnah.
The questioner : Perhaps there are many problems; many people know about it.
The Shaykh : What matters to you? What is your name? Salih? No, Ibrahim, it does not matter to anyone. You follow the Sunnah and the people are sitting and following him.
The questioner : I love it, if Allah wills.
The Shaykh : Did you not know that sujud al-sahw after the salam was not known to the people? And a man I trust told me, and he is now in a high position, that he read a treatise. We used to write a treatise on sujud al-sahw in the past. He said he read it to the people, and they criticized it greatly. What is this new religion? What is in it? Is it complete? He said, "It is better for me to read to you a hadith, the hadith of Abu Hurayrah." He said, "No, we have not known this from our forefathers." You have in you what you do not have. He said, "Okay, we are waiting." That was the days when Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim was the head of the scholars, then Shaykh Ibn Ahmad after him, then Shaykh Ibn Baz the third. He was waiting for him. He had Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim, Shaykh from the gate, the Shaykh did not go out, it is fine. The Shaykh said yes. Shaykh Ibrahim ibn Hamir ibn Bazir said, "We want Shaykh Muhammad ibn Ibrahim." And the Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him) used to sit with the people after Maghrib between two meals. They made an appointment and went to the Shaykh and said, "O long-lived one, this new thing has come: it says to prostrate for forgetfulness after the salam." The Shaykh said, "Okay, he brought you a hadith." They said, "He said to us, 'By Allah, we are not common people, but we have not known this.'" He said, "No, the correct opinion is with him. And now, praise be to Allah, most of the imams apply the Sunnah in this, and the people took it upon themselves. Even the common people now know when the prostration is after the salam and when it is before the prostration. Did you understand?
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 373 - التفريق بين التكبير في الصلاة - شرح تقريب التدمرية - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
