The Ruling on Marrying a Fasiqah (Open Sinner) Woman to a Fasiq (Open Sinner) Man
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Now, there is a problem regarding the open sinners among the daughters of people. Some people consult us, saying: "I have a daughter who is an open sinner. A righteous man does not want her, but an open sinner is asking for her. What should they do?"
The Shaykh : And how do you mean? Do you mean that someone is asking you about her?
The questioner : I mean, this happens a lot nowadays. The daughter is an open sinner, she listens to songs, her prayer is weak, and her father is righteous. So the righteous men do not propose to her. Even if he proposes, out of a sense of trust, he says, "It is not possible to marry her off to this one; she will not become a good wife."
The Shaykh : By Allah, I have a personal concern about this matter. The Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Seize the one with religion," encouraging the one with religion, but he did not prohibit marrying one without religion, except for a disbeliever. This is because a man has authority over a woman. It is rare to find an open sinner woman who remains in her open sinfulness with a righteous man. It is rare, or perhaps there are women, may Allah protect us, who are open sinners but are commanded to do good and obey, to the point that even their husbands cannot manage them. And perhaps she influences her husband as well. So it appears that there is no harm in this. For example, if a man of religion proposes to the father of this woman, and the man knows her condition and there is nothing wrong with him. But if he fears that he did not know about her, and he assumed that because her father is at a good level of religion, she would be like her father, then at that time he should say to him: "Did you know anything about her? Did you know about her condition and her religion?"
The questioner : If the righteous man desires her, that is another matter. If the righteous men do not desire her, then what?
The Shaykh : I mean, if an open sinner proposes to her. If an open sinner proposes to her, but his open sinfulness has not taken him out of the religion, and no righteous man has proposed to her.
The questioner : And there is a likelihood that no one will propose to her.
The Shaykh : Yes, if she is of an age where marriage is difficult, or she has reached an advanced age, then here we marry her off, because righteousness is not a condition for the marriage contract. And delaying it until she grows old has many harms. But if she is young, for example, and many people have proposed to her, then we say: wait, perhaps someone will come who is good for her.
The Shaykh : And how do you mean? Do you mean that someone is asking you about her?
The questioner : I mean, this happens a lot nowadays. The daughter is an open sinner, she listens to songs, her prayer is weak, and her father is righteous. So the righteous men do not propose to her. Even if he proposes, out of a sense of trust, he says, "It is not possible to marry her off to this one; she will not become a good wife."
The Shaykh : By Allah, I have a personal concern about this matter. The Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Seize the one with religion," encouraging the one with religion, but he did not prohibit marrying one without religion, except for a disbeliever. This is because a man has authority over a woman. It is rare to find an open sinner woman who remains in her open sinfulness with a righteous man. It is rare, or perhaps there are women, may Allah protect us, who are open sinners but are commanded to do good and obey, to the point that even their husbands cannot manage them. And perhaps she influences her husband as well. So it appears that there is no harm in this. For example, if a man of religion proposes to the father of this woman, and the man knows her condition and there is nothing wrong with him. But if he fears that he did not know about her, and he assumed that because her father is at a good level of religion, she would be like her father, then at that time he should say to him: "Did you know anything about her? Did you know about her condition and her religion?"
The questioner : If the righteous man desires her, that is another matter. If the righteous men do not desire her, then what?
The Shaykh : I mean, if an open sinner proposes to her. If an open sinner proposes to her, but his open sinfulness has not taken him out of the religion, and no righteous man has proposed to her.
The questioner : And there is a likelihood that no one will propose to her.
The Shaykh : Yes, if she is of an age where marriage is difficult, or she has reached an advanced age, then here we marry her off, because righteousness is not a condition for the marriage contract. And delaying it until she grows old has many harms. But if she is young, for example, and many people have proposed to her, then we say: wait, perhaps someone will come who is good for her.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1961 - 4600 هناك آباء صالحين وعندهم بنات قليل التدين هل يزوجهن للصالحين بدون أن يخبر...؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
