The ruling on the 'Id sacrifice for one who is performing Hajj or has a sacrificial animal
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Even for one who is performing Hajj, Honorable Shaykh, is he allowed to offer the 'Id sacrifice? And if the sacrificial animal is not obligatory for him, is he allowed to offer it?
Answer:
The one who offers the sacrificial animal (hady) is sufficient with it in place of the 'Id sacrifice; because what is required of him is to slaughter during these days and draw near to Allah, so if he slaughters the hady, it suffices him from slaughtering the 'Id sacrifice. However, it is recommended that he have an 'Id sacrifice in his home, even if he performed Hajj and offered the hady, it is recommended that he have an 'Id sacrifice in his home and for his children, acting in accordance with the Sunnah and so that its blessings return to his household. Likewise, the one for whom the hady is not obligatory due to tamattu' or qiran, it is recommended for him to slaughter the hady to participate with the Muslims in drawing near to Allah through slaughter in these days. Yes.
Even for one who is performing Hajj, Honorable Shaykh, is he allowed to offer the 'Id sacrifice? And if the sacrificial animal is not obligatory for him, is he allowed to offer it?
Answer:
The one who offers the sacrificial animal (hady) is sufficient with it in place of the 'Id sacrifice; because what is required of him is to slaughter during these days and draw near to Allah, so if he slaughters the hady, it suffices him from slaughtering the 'Id sacrifice. However, it is recommended that he have an 'Id sacrifice in his home, even if he performed Hajj and offered the hady, it is recommended that he have an 'Id sacrifice in his home and for his children, acting in accordance with the Sunnah and so that its blessings return to his household. Likewise, the one for whom the hady is not obligatory due to tamattu' or qiran, it is recommended for him to slaughter the hady to participate with the Muslims in drawing near to Allah through slaughter in these days. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، توضيح عن مشروعية الأضحية وهل صحيح أن التصدق بثمن الأضحية أفضل من ذبحها؟ الشيخ صالح بن فوزان الفوازن — youtube.com (1:42)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
