A traveler leading the general public: if he fears harm, does he complete the prayer?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Shaykh, may Allah reward you with good. This opinion applies when a person, for example, is leading the general public and fears a commotion, or fears, I mean, people saying this and that.
Answer : By Allah, sometimes I say, yes, he completes the prayer to avoid the harm. And sometimes I say, if the man is a role model, meaning no one can dominate him, and they say, for example, that he is lacking in knowledge or something like that, then let him do the sunnah (recommended practice) that he sees is the sunnah. And if he leaves it and completes the prayer, there is no harm. Is this the one who says it is permissible to shorten? He is not saying it is obligatory. In the opinion of this brother, he holds that shortening is obligatory. But we say it is not obligatory; the original ruling of shortening is not obligatory. And in this matter, if there is doubt in your heart, leave what causes doubt for what does not cause doubt. But if the sunnah becomes clear to you, as the Shaykh al-Islam said, if the sunnah is clear to a person, then there is no, no, no, no basis for caution. Caution lies in following the sunnah.
Answer : By Allah, sometimes I say, yes, he completes the prayer to avoid the harm. And sometimes I say, if the man is a role model, meaning no one can dominate him, and they say, for example, that he is lacking in knowledge or something like that, then let him do the sunnah (recommended practice) that he sees is the sunnah. And if he leaves it and completes the prayer, there is no harm. Is this the one who says it is permissible to shorten? He is not saying it is obligatory. In the opinion of this brother, he holds that shortening is obligatory. But we say it is not obligatory; the original ruling of shortening is not obligatory. And in this matter, if there is doubt in your heart, leave what causes doubt for what does not cause doubt. But if the sunnah becomes clear to you, as the Shaykh al-Islam said, if the sunnah is clear to a person, then there is no, no, no, no basis for caution. Caution lies in following the sunnah.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 3996مسافر يؤم بعامة إذا خاف المفسدة هل يتم؟📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
