The Priority of the Shari'ah over Agreeing with People in Disputes
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : He says: If there is boycott and severance of ties, or something similar, do we agree with the people on this matter, or do we do what the Shari'ah indicates? Let the one who is satisfied be satisfied, and let the one who is angry be angry. Will the anger last this time? It won't last the second time? You may come. Yes. The one asking about it.
The Shaykh : By Allah, I see that the Shari'ah takes precedence. I see that the Shari'ah takes precedence, unless there is a fear that this will lead to something like killing. But as for anger where someone sits for a month, two months, a year, or two years without speaking to you, and then if he marries five or fifteen women from the tribe in a way that is contrary to their custom, and it becomes customary, and the people multiply and it becomes easy, by Allah, I hold that if a wall is breached, it is easy to demolish it, even if it is a cold situation. If a brick falls, what he built falls. In every case, it is weak. I say it is built on weakness, built on weakness. Perhaps they hold that this harms the reputation of the tribe or something similar.
The Shaykh : By Allah, I see that the Shari'ah takes precedence. I see that the Shari'ah takes precedence, unless there is a fear that this will lead to something like killing. But as for anger where someone sits for a month, two months, a year, or two years without speaking to you, and then if he marries five or fifteen women from the tribe in a way that is contrary to their custom, and it becomes customary, and the people multiply and it becomes easy, by Allah, I hold that if a wall is breached, it is easy to demolish it, even if it is a cold situation. If a brick falls, what he built falls. In every case, it is weak. I say it is built on weakness, built on weakness. Perhaps they hold that this harms the reputation of the tribe or something similar.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1894 - 4600 ما الحكم إذا كان الزواج سيخالف عادات القبيلة وسيوافق الشرع لكن يترتب عليه...؟ ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
