The Ruling on Rebuking One Who Holds That Congregational Prayer Is Not Obligatory
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : A questioner says: If a person says, "I hold that congregational prayer is not obligatory," do we rebuke him? Or is this one of the matters of independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) that a person knows about?
Answer : If someone says, "I hold that congregational prayer is not obligatory" based on independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) and research, then we do not rebuke him. However, if he says, "I hold that it is not obligatory" out of ignorance, seeking ease, and following dispensations (rukhas), then we rebuke him. The scholars of knowledge (may Allah have mercy on them) mentioned that following dispensations is a very serious matter. They even said that one who follows a dispensation becomes a Zindiq, meaning his state leads to him becoming a Zindiq, and may Allah protect us from that, and he slips out of the religion without realizing it. I give you an example that illustrates this: A man ate camel meat, touched a woman with his hand without a barrier, and then stood up to pray without ablution. We told him, "Perform ablution, because you ate camel meat, and camel meat invalidates ablution." He said, "I do not follow Imam Ahmad in this; I follow al-Shafi'i, because al-Shafi'i holds that camel meat does not invalidate ablution." We said, "Fine, you touched the woman, and al-Shafi'i holds that touching a woman invalidates ablution, so perform ablution." He said, "I do not follow al-Shafi'i in this, but I follow Imam Ahmad, who holds that touching a woman does not invalidate ablution." If he prays, his prayer is invalid in both cases. His prayer is invalid if he follows al-Shafi'i because of touching the woman, and it is invalid if he follows Imam Ahmad because of eating camel meat. So this man, by following dispensations here and there, prayed without ablution according to both opinions. He prayed without ablution according to both opinions. The point is that we do not rebuke him if he said that based on independent legal reasoning (ijtihad), and we say, "It is between you and your Lord; your Lord is the one who will reward you on the Day of Resurrection." But if he said it out of seeking dispensations without knowledge, then we rebuke him, because the evidence is clear that congregational prayer is obligatory, and that a person sins by abandoning it. Yes.
Answer : If someone says, "I hold that congregational prayer is not obligatory" based on independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) and research, then we do not rebuke him. However, if he says, "I hold that it is not obligatory" out of ignorance, seeking ease, and following dispensations (rukhas), then we rebuke him. The scholars of knowledge (may Allah have mercy on them) mentioned that following dispensations is a very serious matter. They even said that one who follows a dispensation becomes a Zindiq, meaning his state leads to him becoming a Zindiq, and may Allah protect us from that, and he slips out of the religion without realizing it. I give you an example that illustrates this: A man ate camel meat, touched a woman with his hand without a barrier, and then stood up to pray without ablution. We told him, "Perform ablution, because you ate camel meat, and camel meat invalidates ablution." He said, "I do not follow Imam Ahmad in this; I follow al-Shafi'i, because al-Shafi'i holds that camel meat does not invalidate ablution." We said, "Fine, you touched the woman, and al-Shafi'i holds that touching a woman invalidates ablution, so perform ablution." He said, "I do not follow al-Shafi'i in this, but I follow Imam Ahmad, who holds that touching a woman does not invalidate ablution." If he prays, his prayer is invalid in both cases. His prayer is invalid if he follows al-Shafi'i because of touching the woman, and it is invalid if he follows Imam Ahmad because of eating camel meat. So this man, by following dispensations here and there, prayed without ablution according to both opinions. He prayed without ablution according to both opinions. The point is that we do not rebuke him if he said that based on independent legal reasoning (ijtihad), and we say, "It is between you and your Lord; your Lord is the one who will reward you on the Day of Resurrection." But if he said it out of seeking dispensations without knowledge, then we rebuke him, because the evidence is clear that congregational prayer is obligatory, and that a person sins by abandoning it. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [25] حكم الإنكار على من يرى عدم وجوب صلاة الجماعة - فوائد الخطب والمحاضرات - ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
