Text copied Link copied

Al-Fatawa – home

﴿ فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

Scholar
Search mode

The Ruling on Selling Dead Land to One Who Has Begun to Revive It but Has Not Completed the Work

Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : This is an important issue. For example, a person begins to revive land but does not complete the work, or he is granted the land but does not revive it. If we say that the imam’s grant is not revival, but if we say it is revival, then the matter is clear. The important point is that he has become more entitled to this land, either because he fenced it in a way that does not give him ownership, or because he began to revive it but did not complete it, or because it was granted to him by the one in authority, and we said that the grant is not a transfer of ownership. Is it permissible for him to take compensation and relinquish it?

Answer : This is the position of the madhhab: it is not permissible. Because one of the conditions of a sale is that the seller owns the item, and this person does not own it. If he does not own it, how is it permissible for him to sell it when it is not his property? Al-Muqaddim, Ibn Qudamah, says that it is possible that selling it is permissible because he has become more entitled to it. So this sale is not a sale of the land itself, but rather a relinquishment of his right for compensation. A relinquishment. He says, “I have now begun to revive it but did not complete it, or I was granted it and that was not revival, so I relinquish my right to so-and-so for compensation.” So Ibn Qudamah (may Allah have mercy on him) says that its permissibility is possible. Let us look into it.
We say that if we apply this to the general principles, there is no harm in a person relinquishing his right to another for compensation or for free, because the right is his. But the question remains: is there harm to others? Because there may be a group who are more entitled to it than the last person.
The first person usually does not sell it except because he no longer needs it. If he no longer needs it, let him relinquish it and give it to the one in authority, and the one in authority grants it to the one who is more entitled to it. This is the point that necessitates us saying that it is not permissible to relinquish it for compensation. Why?
Say, people, because it is an encroachment on the others who submitted applications and were more entitled than he was. The seller is now content; if he is content, let he return the matter to those who are entitled to it. If someone asks, “If they granted it to him for free, meaning as a favor, is it permissible or not?” We say that if we look at the reasoning, we find that it is not permissible either. So we say, if you no longer need it, return it to the government, for example. You have not finished.
Source قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [5569] حكم بيع الموات ممن شرع في إحيائه ولم يتم - تعليقات على الكافي لابن عثيمين — youtube.com
Flag this fatwa