Clarifying the meaning of [Whoever says: "The Qur'an is created" has denied the command and the prohibition]
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh, may Allah bless you. The statement that the Qur'an is created has caused him confusion. As we have passed through, Shaykh al-Islam mentioned that this denies the command and the prohibition, making everything created. But Shaykh, does this not pose a problem? A created being also speaks with created speech, and it contains commands and prohibitions, and it contains questions and so on?
The Shaykh : Yes, that is correct.
The questioner : I mean, it does not necessarily follow. This is a false statement, but the necessary consequence is not necessarily so.
The Shaykh : No, it is necessary. He says that Allah created sounds, but they do not indicate a command or a prohibition. Command and prohibition are impossible; they are merely like shapes if they are false, or like the sounds of thunder and lightning if they are heard.
The questioner : But Shaykh, does not a created being write created speech with his own speech?
The Shaykh : Yes, it is created because the human being is created.
The questioner : Well, does this then contain commands and prohibitions, questions, and so on?
The Shaykh : It does, it does. And we say our speech is created. Our speech is created, and we make it with our hands if we write it, and we pronounce it with our tongues if we speak it. I mean, if we now say that it is created, it is as if Allah the Exalted made sounds heard, but they do not contain a command or a prohibition. And if it is written, it is as if Allah the Exalted created things in specific shapes only, that do not indicate a command or a prohibition. Reflect on it; it is clear. And a time has passed for me, and I was reflecting on the words of Ibn al-Qayyim and Shaykh al-Islam that this invalidates the command and the prohibition, and I would say how is that, until what I heard became clear to me.
The Shaykh : Yes, that is correct.
The questioner : I mean, it does not necessarily follow. This is a false statement, but the necessary consequence is not necessarily so.
The Shaykh : No, it is necessary. He says that Allah created sounds, but they do not indicate a command or a prohibition. Command and prohibition are impossible; they are merely like shapes if they are false, or like the sounds of thunder and lightning if they are heard.
The questioner : But Shaykh, does not a created being write created speech with his own speech?
The Shaykh : Yes, it is created because the human being is created.
The questioner : Well, does this then contain commands and prohibitions, questions, and so on?
The Shaykh : It does, it does. And we say our speech is created. Our speech is created, and we make it with our hands if we write it, and we pronounce it with our tongues if we speak it. I mean, if we now say that it is created, it is as if Allah the Exalted made sounds heard, but they do not contain a command or a prohibition. And if it is written, it is as if Allah the Exalted created things in specific shapes only, that do not indicate a command or a prohibition. Reflect on it; it is clear. And a time has passed for me, and I was reflecting on the words of Ibn al-Qayyim and Shaykh al-Islam that this invalidates the command and the prohibition, and I would say how is that, until what I heard became clear to me.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [353] توضيح معنى [من قال: إن القرآن مخلوق فقد عطل الأمر والنهي] - الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين — youtube.com
