The Ruling on the Marriage of the Second Husband Between Divorces
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : A woman was divorced by her husband with three divorces, and another husband intervened between them. Is she forbidden to the first husband until she marries a man other than him?
The Shaykh : That is, she was divorced twice. No other husband intervened between them. He divorced her twice, then another man married her, then that other man divorced her, and she returned to the first. She returns based only on what remained of her divorces; that is, she does not restart the count of divorces. Accordingly, if he divorces her for the third time, she is forbidden to him until she marries another man. Do you understand? Now, if someone asks: How is it that the husband destroys the three divorces but not the two? The answer is that the two are not destroyed because the right of the first husband, who divorced her twice, to take her back (raj'ah) does not depend on the marriage to the second husband. Therefore, the marriage to the second husband had no effect and did not destroy the two. However, if it was three, we say here that the marriage to the second husband had an effect, which was to make her lawful for the first husband, so she returns with three divorces.
The Shaykh : That is, she was divorced twice. No other husband intervened between them. He divorced her twice, then another man married her, then that other man divorced her, and she returned to the first. She returns based only on what remained of her divorces; that is, she does not restart the count of divorces. Accordingly, if he divorces her for the third time, she is forbidden to him until she marries another man. Do you understand? Now, if someone asks: How is it that the husband destroys the three divorces but not the two? The answer is that the two are not destroyed because the right of the first husband, who divorced her twice, to take her back (raj'ah) does not depend on the marriage to the second husband. Therefore, the marriage to the second husband had no effect and did not destroy the two. However, if it was three, we say here that the marriage to the second husband had an effect, which was to make her lawful for the first husband, so she returns with three divorces.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 210 - 332 امرأة طلقها زوجها ثلاث تطليقات وتخلل بينها زوج آخر هل تحرم على الزوج الأول...؟ — youtube.com
