The ruling on selling the fruit of an orchard with mixed varieties when ripeness has appeared in some but not others
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : But if he sells them
The Shaykh : all together, and they are of multiple varieties, we say that a variety is like a single tree. If ripeness appears in a variety, it is considered to have appeared in the entire variety. For example, a man has an orchard with palm trees of different types: Sukkari, Barhi, Shiqar, and Umm al-Hamam—four varieties. If he sells them all together, and we find that ripeness has appeared in one of the Barhi trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Sukkari trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Shiqar trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Umm al-Hamam trees while the rest have not, if he sells them all together, we say there is no harm, because this is one type, and ripeness has appeared in one tree of it, and the transaction is one, so it is valid.
The Shaykh : all together, and they are of multiple varieties, we say that a variety is like a single tree. If ripeness appears in a variety, it is considered to have appeared in the entire variety. For example, a man has an orchard with palm trees of different types: Sukkari, Barhi, Shiqar, and Umm al-Hamam—four varieties. If he sells them all together, and we find that ripeness has appeared in one of the Barhi trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Sukkari trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Shiqar trees while the rest have not, or ripeness has appeared in one of the Umm al-Hamam trees while the rest have not, if he sells them all together, we say there is no harm, because this is one type, and ripeness has appeared in one tree of it, and the transaction is one, so it is valid.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [4157] حكم من باع ثمر بستان متنوع الأجناس قد بدا الصلاح في بعضها دون الأخرى - تعليقات على الكافي — youtube.com
