How does one pay zakah on the profits of commercial projects?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. All praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds. And may Allah send prayers and blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad, and upon his family and his Companions, with abundant peace until the Day of Judgment. I said: May Allah send prayers upon him. May Allah send prayers and blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad, and upon his family and all his Companions. As for what follows, Honorable Shaykh, may Allah reward you. A questioner says: A man has a commercial shop, and he has taken out profits from it. He used to pay the full zakah whenever the lunar year of possession (hawl) completed for it. After that, he took these profits from this activity and established another commercial project with them. He was not successful in it and did not benefit much from it. So the question is: Does he pay zakah on the first capital separately, and on the second separately? Or does he pay on the first and its profits as he used to, without paying on the second?
Answer : The question is ambiguous, but I say that trade goods (‘urud al-tijarah) require a person to pay their zakah on both the capital and the profit. For example, if a person has a property that he bought for one hundred thousand, and when the time for zakah arrived, it was worth one hundred and twenty thousand.
He must pay zakah on one hundred and twenty thousand, because the profit follows the principal. Even if this profit was not realized until one month before the zakah became obligatory, he pays on the principal and the profit. And the reverse is the reverse: if he bought a property for one hundred thousand intending to trade with it, and when the zakah became obligatory it was worth only eighty thousand, what is obligatory for him? He pays zakah on eighty thousand. And know that the hawl (lunar year) for trade goods is the hawl of their principal. If he bought this property in the middle of the year.
Do we say he does not pay zakah on it until the hawl completes from the time of its purchase, or does he pay zakah when the hawl completes from the time of his original capital? The answer is the second, meaning he pays zakah when the hawl completes from the original capital. An example of this is a man who has one hundred thousand riyals, which he owned in Muharram. In Rajab, he bought land for one hundred thousand riyals intending to trade with it. Then Muharram of the second year arrived. He has had the land for six months, but he has had the original capital for a year. Is zakah obligatory on him in Muharram based on the original capital, or do we wait until Rajab arrives based on the purchase of the trade goods? The first option, meaning he must pay zakah on it in Muharram, because the hawl of trade goods is the hawl of their principal. Yes.
Answer : The question is ambiguous, but I say that trade goods (‘urud al-tijarah) require a person to pay their zakah on both the capital and the profit. For example, if a person has a property that he bought for one hundred thousand, and when the time for zakah arrived, it was worth one hundred and twenty thousand.
He must pay zakah on one hundred and twenty thousand, because the profit follows the principal. Even if this profit was not realized until one month before the zakah became obligatory, he pays on the principal and the profit. And the reverse is the reverse: if he bought a property for one hundred thousand intending to trade with it, and when the zakah became obligatory it was worth only eighty thousand, what is obligatory for him? He pays zakah on eighty thousand. And know that the hawl (lunar year) for trade goods is the hawl of their principal. If he bought this property in the middle of the year.
Do we say he does not pay zakah on it until the hawl completes from the time of its purchase, or does he pay zakah when the hawl completes from the time of his original capital? The answer is the second, meaning he pays zakah when the hawl completes from the original capital. An example of this is a man who has one hundred thousand riyals, which he owned in Muharram. In Rajab, he bought land for one hundred thousand riyals intending to trade with it. Then Muharram of the second year arrived. He has had the land for six months, but he has had the original capital for a year. Is zakah obligatory on him in Muharram based on the original capital, or do we wait until Rajab arrives based on the purchase of the trade goods? The first option, meaning he must pay zakah on it in Muharram, because the hawl of trade goods is the hawl of their principal. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[29 من 145] كيف يزكي أرباح المشاريع التجارية؟ الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء — youtube.com
