The ruling on saying "if Allah wills" after performing the prayer
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : May Allah reward you. Sometimes, Shaykh, people say to someone, "Pray," and he says, "If Allah wills." Or they say, "You are a Muslim," and he says, "If Allah wills."
Answer : And they say, "Have you eaten?" and he says, "If Allah wills." Or, "Have you put on your clothes?" and he says, "If Allah wills." Yes, indeed. These people, if they say, "I prayed," and then say, "If Allah wills," intending by this phrase that it is a valid prayer or a prayer that results in reward, then this is correct. This is because not every prayer in the physical sense is a prayer in the legal sense. There is no prayer in the presence of food, nor while one is struggling to relieve oneself, nor while the call to prayer is being recited, even though he is praying in the physical sense. So, if the one praying intends by his saying "if Allah wills" that it is a prayer that results in reward, then there is no harm in it. I think this is what people intend; that is, they intend that they have prayed an accepted prayer. However, if he says, "I prayed, if Allah wills," there is no place for this condition if he intends only the occurrence of the prayer. In that case, there is no need for it; it is idle talk, just as if he said, "I put on my clothes, if Allah wills." But the common people exaggerate in such matters and they do not know. As our Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him), 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Sa'di, told us about a person.
They told him that they asked him about the dates he had stored. People used to store dates in houses called al-jisat, which are large. So they said to him, "O so-and-so, how are your dates?" He said, "By Allah, they are finished. How are they finished when there is so much of them? Who ate them?" He said, "Allah ate them, then us," meaning like these people: "Allah, then you."
So he made everything include "then," associating Allah with "then." This is a common thing that he did not know. But Allah the Exalted did not eat them. So it appears that their saying "if Allah wills" intends that the prayer be accepted, because women do not know whether it is accepted or not. They do not intend the custom of making an exception regarding the act.
Answer : And they say, "Have you eaten?" and he says, "If Allah wills." Or, "Have you put on your clothes?" and he says, "If Allah wills." Yes, indeed. These people, if they say, "I prayed," and then say, "If Allah wills," intending by this phrase that it is a valid prayer or a prayer that results in reward, then this is correct. This is because not every prayer in the physical sense is a prayer in the legal sense. There is no prayer in the presence of food, nor while one is struggling to relieve oneself, nor while the call to prayer is being recited, even though he is praying in the physical sense. So, if the one praying intends by his saying "if Allah wills" that it is a prayer that results in reward, then there is no harm in it. I think this is what people intend; that is, they intend that they have prayed an accepted prayer. However, if he says, "I prayed, if Allah wills," there is no place for this condition if he intends only the occurrence of the prayer. In that case, there is no need for it; it is idle talk, just as if he said, "I put on my clothes, if Allah wills." But the common people exaggerate in such matters and they do not know. As our Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him), 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Sa'di, told us about a person.
They told him that they asked him about the dates he had stored. People used to store dates in houses called al-jisat, which are large. So they said to him, "O so-and-so, how are your dates?" He said, "By Allah, they are finished. How are they finished when there is so much of them? Who ate them?" He said, "Allah ate them, then us," meaning like these people: "Allah, then you."
So he made everything include "then," associating Allah with "then." This is a common thing that he did not know. But Allah the Exalted did not eat them. So it appears that their saying "if Allah wills" intends that the prayer be accepted, because women do not know whether it is accepted or not. They do not intend the custom of making an exception regarding the act.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 4377 - 4600 ما حكم قول بعض الناس عندما يسأل أصليت فيقول إن شاء الله ويقال له أنت مسلم...؟ ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
