The Clearest and Most Explicit Response to Those Who Argue with Divine Decree
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The most losing answer we give them is: What makes you think that Allah willed for you to associate partners with Him? Do we know that Allah willed something except after it has occurred? Is their proceeding to do it based on evidence, or not based on evidence? If Allah wills.
The Shaykh : It is not based on evidence, because they do not know. Therefore, their argument is invalid. This is the most noble and clearest response to them: to say that you do not know what Allah has decreed for you until it has happened. So why did you not assume that Allah decreed good for you and act upon the good?
The questioner : I mean that they do not go out from the will of Allah; it is not by derivation.
The Shaykh : Nothing goes out from the will of Allah. There is nothing in the heavens or on the earth except by the will of Allah, without doubt. But for a person to proceed to disobey the command of Allah while he does not know what Allah willed for him, this is an error. Yes.
The Shaykh : It is not based on evidence, because they do not know. Therefore, their argument is invalid. This is the most noble and clearest response to them: to say that you do not know what Allah has decreed for you until it has happened. So why did you not assume that Allah decreed good for you and act upon the good?
The questioner : I mean that they do not go out from the will of Allah; it is not by derivation.
The Shaykh : Nothing goes out from the will of Allah. There is nothing in the heavens or on the earth except by the will of Allah, without doubt. But for a person to proceed to disobey the command of Allah while he does not know what Allah willed for him, this is an error. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 503 - أوضح وأبين رد على من يحتج بالقدر - شرح تقريب التدمرية - ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
