Regarding praying in a thawb: If one leaves the hands out of the sleeves, is that considered complete covering (ishtimal al-samaw)?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Regarding prayer, O Shaykh: If one does not put the hands inside the sleeves, is that considered complete covering (ishtimal al-samaw)?
Answer : No, it is not considered complete covering (ishtimal al-samaw). But tell me, is it considered the disliked letting down (sadal)? Or is it not? The Shaykh al-Islam said that it is not the disliked letting down, neither in a thawb nor a qaba. So if a person puts the garment on his shoulders and does not put his hands in the sleeves, it is not disliked.
Answer : No, it is not considered complete covering (ishtimal al-samaw). But tell me, is it considered the disliked letting down (sadal)? Or is it not? The Shaykh al-Islam said that it is not the disliked letting down, neither in a thawb nor a qaba. So if a person puts the garment on his shoulders and does not put his hands in the sleeves, it is not disliked.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 745 - بالنسبة للصلاة في المشلح لو ترك إدخال اليدين في المشلح هل تعتبر من اشتمال الصماء؟ — youtube.com
