Are there weak reports in the book of Tawhid?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
He says: Some students of knowledge explain the book of Tawhid, and in their explanation they weaken many of the reports found in this book. Is what he or others mention correct?
Answer:
This is a demolition of the book; it is not an explanation. This is a demolition of the book. So, this is what is appropriate. Yes. And this is what is known of the author's methodology. One does not know the author's methodology in his presentation of the evidence. He presents a chapter, in which there is no verse or authentic hadith, and then he mentions what follows, meaning the meaning of the verse and the meaning of the hadith. So, the author is on a sound methodology, but this person does not understand the author's methodology. Honorable Shaykh, whoever explains any book should first look at the methodology of its author, and then follow it. Yes.
He says: Some students of knowledge explain the book of Tawhid, and in their explanation they weaken many of the reports found in this book. Is what he or others mention correct?
Answer:
This is a demolition of the book; it is not an explanation. This is a demolition of the book. So, this is what is appropriate. Yes. And this is what is known of the author's methodology. One does not know the author's methodology in his presentation of the evidence. He presents a chapter, in which there is no verse or authentic hadith, and then he mentions what follows, meaning the meaning of the verse and the meaning of the hadith. So, the author is on a sound methodology, but this person does not understand the author's methodology. Honorable Shaykh, whoever explains any book should first look at the methodology of its author, and then follow it. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، هل توجد آثار ضعيفة في كتاب التوحيد؟ لمعالي الشيخ صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.