Children who used to steal some candy from grocery stores, and now that they have grown up, who should give charity for its value: they or their parents?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: There were children who used to go to grocery stores and take some candy without paying for it, out of ignorance. Now these children have grown up and told their mother about it. So who should give charity for its value? Is it them, or their mother, or their father? Or should charity be given for its value, which was taken from people’s money?
Answer:
They should return the price to the one from whom it was taken and ask him for forgiveness, as long as the owners are still present and known. If what was taken from them is still available, they return it in kind; if it has been consumed, they return its value and ask them for forgiveness. If it is not possible to identify them, then they give charity for the price, and the reward belongs to the one from whom it was taken. Yes.
May Allah reward you, Honorable Shaykh. This questioner says: There were children who used to go to grocery stores and take some candy without paying for it, out of ignorance. Now these children have grown up and told their mother about it. So who should give charity for its value? Is it them, or their mother, or their father? Or should charity be given for its value, which was taken from people’s money?
Answer:
They should return the price to the one from whom it was taken and ask him for forgiveness, as long as the owners are still present and known. If what was taken from them is still available, they return it in kind; if it has been consumed, they return its value and ask them for forgiveness. If it is not possible to identify them, then they give charity for the price, and the reward belongs to the one from whom it was taken. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [14 -954] أطفال كانوا يسرقون من البقالات بعض الحلوى، والآن كبروا فمن يتصدق بقيمتها، هُم أم والديهم؟ — youtube.com
