What is your opinion on *al-Dr al-Manthur* by Imam al-Suyuti and *Fath al-Qadir* by al-Shawkani?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, are al-Suyuti’s *al-Dr al-Manthur* and al-Shawkani’s *Fath al-Qadir* considered tafsirs?
The Shaykh:
*al-Dr al-Manthur* is by al-Suyuti. This al-Suyuti collected the athar (reports) that have been transmitted regarding the tafsir of the Qur'an, from hadiths and the sayings of the Salaf. So it is a tafsir; it is a good book. They are the ones who collected the narrations in tafsir. It is a great record for the tafsir of the Qur'an. This is a good thing. And the second one,
The questioner:
al-Shawkani’s tafsir, *Fath al-Qadir*.
The Shaykh:
Al-Shawkani, yes. He says between *riwayah* (narration) and *dirayah* (analysis). *Riwayah* and *dirayah*. *Riwayah* is correct, but as for *dirayah*, this is a matter of consideration. However, his intention, and Allah knows best, is the *dirayah* that is the requirement of the Arabic language. Because one of the aspects of tafsir, if there is no tafsir by hadith, nor by the saying of a Companion, nor by the saying of a Successor, is that it is interpreted by the language in which it was revealed, which is the Arabic language. Yes.
He says: Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, are al-Suyuti’s *al-Dr al-Manthur* and al-Shawkani’s *Fath al-Qadir* considered tafsirs?
The Shaykh:
*al-Dr al-Manthur* is by al-Suyuti. This al-Suyuti collected the athar (reports) that have been transmitted regarding the tafsir of the Qur'an, from hadiths and the sayings of the Salaf. So it is a tafsir; it is a good book. They are the ones who collected the narrations in tafsir. It is a great record for the tafsir of the Qur'an. This is a good thing. And the second one,
The questioner:
al-Shawkani’s tafsir, *Fath al-Qadir*.
The Shaykh:
Al-Shawkani, yes. He says between *riwayah* (narration) and *dirayah* (analysis). *Riwayah* and *dirayah*. *Riwayah* is correct, but as for *dirayah*, this is a matter of consideration. However, his intention, and Allah knows best, is the *dirayah* that is the requirement of the Arabic language. Because one of the aspects of tafsir, if there is no tafsir by hadith, nor by the saying of a Companion, nor by the saying of a Successor, is that it is interpreted by the language in which it was revealed, which is the Arabic language. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [3674- 4717] ما رأيكم في تفسير الدر المنثور للإمام السيوطي وتفسير فتح القدير للشوكاني؟ -صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
