Is the one who abandons prayer out of negligence a disbeliever in major kufr (disbelief)?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The questioner says: Some scholars have stated that the one who abandons prayer out of negligence is a disbeliever, but it is a kufr (disbelief) that is not kufr (disbelief). Is this correct?
The Shaykh : This statement is not correct, because the kufr (disbelief) indicated by the Book, the Sunnah, and the statements of the Companions regarding the one who abandons prayer is major kufr (disbelief) that expels one from the religion. We have previously, before this session, explained the evidence indicating the kufr (disbelief) of the one who abandons prayer from the Book of Allah, the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), the statements of the Companions (may Allah be pleased with them), and the correct understanding. We clarified that every piece of evidence cited by those who say he does not commit major kufr (disbelief) that expels one from the religion contains no indication for the one who cited it, and that those pieces of evidence do not exceed four cases. Who can answer for us? The evidence cited by those who say the one who abandons prayer does not commit major kufr (disbelief); we mentioned that it does not fall outside of four cases. Most of you were not present when we discussed this.
The first case is that there is no indication in it at all. The second case is that it is restricted to a state in which abandoning prayer is not possible. The third case is that it is restricted to a state in which a person is excused for abandoning prayer. The fourth case is that it is general, but it is specified by texts or by the texts indicating the kufr (disbelief) of the one who abandons prayer.
We have also explained previously that the ruling on kufr (disbelief) and iman (faith) is not taken except from the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), and that we have no right to describe a person as a disbeliever without the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) indicating that. Because saying to a person that he is a disbeliever is like saying about a thing that it is haram (forbidden). Just as it is not permissible for us to say about a thing that it is haram (forbidden) except with evidence from the Book and the Sunnah, so it is not permissible for us to say about a person that he is a disbeliever except with evidence from the Book and the Sunnah. Obligatory. Do you consider him a disbeliever or not? He is a disbeliever.
Denial, even if it is not accompanied by abandonment, is kufr (disbelief). The narrations and texts regarding this matter only attached the ruling to abandonment. If you say that the intended meaning is the denier, you have nullified the description to which the Lawgiver attached the ruling and introduced a new description that the Shari'ah did not consider. By this, you have committed a sin against the text in two ways. In two ways: the first is nullifying its indication, and the second is considering a description that the Lawgiver did not consider. A person should fear his Lord, for he is not the decider, but he is judged. If the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger indicate a ruling, why do we try to escape from it?
Therefore, when it was said to Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) that so-and-so says that the statement of Allah the Exalted[An-Nisa 4:93] was said to Imam Ahmad that so-and-so says this regarding the one who considers killing permissible. Meaning [An-Nisa 4:93] one who considers killing permissible. Imam Ahmad said: Subhan Allah, the one who considers killing a believer permissible is a disbeliever, whether he killed or did not kill? The verse attached the ruling to killing. This person who says that the one who abandons it while denying its obligation, and inserts the word "denying its obligation" into the hadith of the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him), we say to him: Subhan Allah, the denier is a disbeliever, whether he abandoned it or did not abandon it. And the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) attached the ruling to abandonment. If there were texts indicating that the one who abandons prayer does not commit kufr (disbelief), we would be compelled to interpret the texts indicating his kufr (disbelief) to mean abandoning it while denying its obligation. But I say that there is absolutely no authentic, explicit text indicating that the one who abandons prayer is not a disbeliever. If a text came to us saying that the one who abandons prayer does not commit kufr (disbelief), and then a text came saying that the one who abandons prayer has committed kufr (disbelief), at that time we would reconcile the two texts and say: the one who abandons it while denying it commits kufr (disbelief), and the one who abandons prayer while not denying it does not commit kufr (disbelief). But since there is no... but since there has not come a bold... authentic, explicit text that the one who abandons prayer does not commit kufr (disbelief).
And beyond that, it is a distortion of the text, for it is not possible to distort the texts from what they indicate. And this, I mean, the one who says "the one who abandons it while denying its obligation," this is distorting words from their places. And I have informed you now that there is distortion in it in two ways: nullifying what the Lawgiver considered, and considering what the Lawgiver did not consider. The one who is...
There is no doubt that the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" is a Muslim, but the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" is restricted by his saying "seeking thereby the Face of Allah." If it is said "seeking thereby the Face of Allah," does the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" seeking thereby the Face of Allah pray or not? He prays, without doubt, because the one who seeks a thing must necessarily ask for it. Then, on the assumption that it came in an absolute form, such as "the one who says La ilaha illa Allah will enter Paradise," this is a general phrase that is specified by abandoning prayer. Just as, for example, if a person says "La ilaha illa Allah, I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah," and he lies about one report from the reports of the Qur'an, he would be a disbeliever, even if he said "La ilaha illa Allah."
Yes, he has never done any good. This hadith is general; it is specified by the hadith of the kufr (disbelief) of prayer, specified by the hadiths of the kufr (disbelief) of prayer. Just as this person who said "La ilaha illa Allah" and never did any good, if he had denied something from the Qur'an, it would not have benefited him. If he said "La ilaha illa Allah," yes, he has never done any good. It is said: this person has never done any good. It is specified by the hadiths of abandoning prayer, and it is said: except the one who abandons prayer, for he does not come out of the Fire, by the evidence of the texts indicating his kufr (disbelief). And this is the fourth case I told you about; the fourth case is that they are general texts specified by the texts of abandoning prayer.
The questioner : Allah the Exalted says: "And whoever does not make what Allah has revealed lawful, those are the disbelievers."
The Shaykh : As for the one who prays one obligatory prayer and abandons another obligatory prayer while acknowledging its obligation, what I see is that he does not commit kufr (disbelief). Because the hadith says: "Between a man and shirk (associating partners with Allah) and kufr (disbelief) is the abandonment of prayer," and it did not say "the abandonment of a prayer." And there is a difference between abandoning prayer and abandoning a prayer. And likewise, the covenant between Us and them is prayer, so whoever abandons it has committed kufr (disbelief). Abandons it, meaning prayer. So the one who prays one obligatory prayer and leaves another obligatory prayer while acknowledging its obligation, what I see is that he does not commit kufr (disbelief). Yes.
The questioner : The hadith: "Whoever intentionally abandons a time (of prayer)..." is it authentic?
The Shaykh : No, it is weak.
The questioner : This word says: "And whoever does not fear what Allah has revealed..." Is it not a question?
The Shaykh : This statement is not correct, because the kufr (disbelief) indicated by the Book, the Sunnah, and the statements of the Companions regarding the one who abandons prayer is major kufr (disbelief) that expels one from the religion. We have previously, before this session, explained the evidence indicating the kufr (disbelief) of the one who abandons prayer from the Book of Allah, the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), the statements of the Companions (may Allah be pleased with them), and the correct understanding. We clarified that every piece of evidence cited by those who say he does not commit major kufr (disbelief) that expels one from the religion contains no indication for the one who cited it, and that those pieces of evidence do not exceed four cases. Who can answer for us? The evidence cited by those who say the one who abandons prayer does not commit major kufr (disbelief); we mentioned that it does not fall outside of four cases. Most of you were not present when we discussed this.
The first case is that there is no indication in it at all. The second case is that it is restricted to a state in which abandoning prayer is not possible. The third case is that it is restricted to a state in which a person is excused for abandoning prayer. The fourth case is that it is general, but it is specified by texts or by the texts indicating the kufr (disbelief) of the one who abandons prayer.
We have also explained previously that the ruling on kufr (disbelief) and iman (faith) is not taken except from the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), and that we have no right to describe a person as a disbeliever without the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) indicating that. Because saying to a person that he is a disbeliever is like saying about a thing that it is haram (forbidden). Just as it is not permissible for us to say about a thing that it is haram (forbidden) except with evidence from the Book and the Sunnah, so it is not permissible for us to say about a person that he is a disbeliever except with evidence from the Book and the Sunnah. Obligatory. Do you consider him a disbeliever or not? He is a disbeliever.
Denial, even if it is not accompanied by abandonment, is kufr (disbelief). The narrations and texts regarding this matter only attached the ruling to abandonment. If you say that the intended meaning is the denier, you have nullified the description to which the Lawgiver attached the ruling and introduced a new description that the Shari'ah did not consider. By this, you have committed a sin against the text in two ways. In two ways: the first is nullifying its indication, and the second is considering a description that the Lawgiver did not consider. A person should fear his Lord, for he is not the decider, but he is judged. If the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger indicate a ruling, why do we try to escape from it?
Therefore, when it was said to Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) that so-and-so says that the statement of Allah the Exalted
But whoever kills a believer intentionally - his recompense is Hell, wherein he will abide eternally
وَمَن يَقْتُلْ مُؤْمِنًا مُّتَعَمِّدًا فَجَزَاؤُهُ جَهَنَّمُ خَالِدًا فِيهَاBut whoever kills a believer
وَمَن يَقْتُلْ مُؤْمِنًاAnd beyond that, it is a distortion of the text, for it is not possible to distort the texts from what they indicate. And this, I mean, the one who says "the one who abandons it while denying its obligation," this is distorting words from their places. And I have informed you now that there is distortion in it in two ways: nullifying what the Lawgiver considered, and considering what the Lawgiver did not consider. The one who is...
There is no doubt that the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" is a Muslim, but the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" is restricted by his saying "seeking thereby the Face of Allah." If it is said "seeking thereby the Face of Allah," does the one who says "La ilaha illa Allah" seeking thereby the Face of Allah pray or not? He prays, without doubt, because the one who seeks a thing must necessarily ask for it. Then, on the assumption that it came in an absolute form, such as "the one who says La ilaha illa Allah will enter Paradise," this is a general phrase that is specified by abandoning prayer. Just as, for example, if a person says "La ilaha illa Allah, I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah," and he lies about one report from the reports of the Qur'an, he would be a disbeliever, even if he said "La ilaha illa Allah."
Yes, he has never done any good. This hadith is general; it is specified by the hadith of the kufr (disbelief) of prayer, specified by the hadiths of the kufr (disbelief) of prayer. Just as this person who said "La ilaha illa Allah" and never did any good, if he had denied something from the Qur'an, it would not have benefited him. If he said "La ilaha illa Allah," yes, he has never done any good. It is said: this person has never done any good. It is specified by the hadiths of abandoning prayer, and it is said: except the one who abandons prayer, for he does not come out of the Fire, by the evidence of the texts indicating his kufr (disbelief). And this is the fourth case I told you about; the fourth case is that they are general texts specified by the texts of abandoning prayer.
The questioner : Allah the Exalted says: "And whoever does not make what Allah has revealed lawful, those are the disbelievers."
The Shaykh : As for the one who prays one obligatory prayer and abandons another obligatory prayer while acknowledging its obligation, what I see is that he does not commit kufr (disbelief). Because the hadith says: "Between a man and shirk (associating partners with Allah) and kufr (disbelief) is the abandonment of prayer," and it did not say "the abandonment of a prayer." And there is a difference between abandoning prayer and abandoning a prayer. And likewise, the covenant between Us and them is prayer, so whoever abandons it has committed kufr (disbelief). Abandons it, meaning prayer. So the one who prays one obligatory prayer and leaves another obligatory prayer while acknowledging its obligation, what I see is that he does not commit kufr (disbelief). Yes.
The questioner : The hadith: "Whoever intentionally abandons a time (of prayer)..." is it authentic?
The Shaykh : No, it is weak.
The questioner : This word says: "And whoever does not fear what Allah has revealed..." Is it not a question?
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2 - 12 - دروس وفتاوى المسجد الحرام للعام 1406 هـ - الدرس الثاني - الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين — youtube.com (11:34)
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
