A woman who broke her fast upon the hospital adhan, then was informed that the hospital adhan was incorrect: is she required to make up the fasts?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success. A woman from outside Riyadh accompanied her sick daughter in the hospital. Yes. A woman from outside Riyadh accompanied her sick daughter in the hospital for most of the days of Ramadan, and every day she broke her fast upon the adhan broadcast from the hospital through the speakers inside the rooms. Then, after fifteen days, a woman came to her and informed her that the adhan in this hospital is incorrect, and that it is at least five minutes before sunset. What should she do with those days? And is she required to make them up?
Answer:
She is not required to make them up, and the adhan in the hospital is approved, officially approved. Do not believe this woman; this woman is mistaken. Yes.
Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success. A woman from outside Riyadh accompanied her sick daughter in the hospital. Yes. A woman from outside Riyadh accompanied her sick daughter in the hospital for most of the days of Ramadan, and every day she broke her fast upon the adhan broadcast from the hospital through the speakers inside the rooms. Then, after fifteen days, a woman came to her and informed her that the adhan in this hospital is incorrect, and that it is at least five minutes before sunset. What should she do with those days? And is she required to make them up?
Answer:
She is not required to make them up, and the adhan in the hospital is approved, officially approved. Do not believe this woman; this woman is mistaken. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [3408- 4717] امرأة كانت تفطر على أذان المستشفى ثم أخبرت أن أذان المستشفى غير صحيح فهل يلزمها القضاء؟ — youtube.com
