A woman died while pregnant in her ninth month, and the doctor said the fetus was alive, so her husband refused to have it removed. Is he sinful?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
Umm 'Umar says: Honorable Shaykh, my father passed away twenty-five years ago. Two years before his death, my aunt, his first wife, died while pregnant in her ninth month. The doctor said the fetus was alive and that we could perform a cesarean section to save it. My father refused, saying the fetus was not more valuable than its mother, and he was confused about who would raise it. At the same time, he left it as it was because he did not know that it was not permissible. Is my father sinful for that, and is he considered to have caused the killing of a soul? If so, what is the expiation we should pay on his behalf so that he is not punished in his grave? The reason we delayed asking is that we did not know the ruling. Also, we were in pain in that situation, and we were young. May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh:
Your father owes nothing in this matter, because it has not been established that the fetus died due to the failure to perform the operation to remove it. The operation might have been performed, and the fetus might have come out dead, or it might have died during the procedure. It has not been established that its death was caused by not performing the operation. Furthermore, performing such an operation requires the confirmation of trustworthy doctors who certify that the fetus is alive and that removing it will not harm the mother, among other conditions. Therefore, your father owes nothing in this; because the causality in the fetus's death was not established. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good and do you good.
The questioner:
In the previous question, Shaykh Salih, if the doctor mentions that the fetus is alive in the belly of a deceased woman, and that by performing a cesarean section it can be removed alive, by the will of Allah, is the operation performed in that case or not?
The Shaykh:
If the mother is dead, and the doctor determines that the fetus is alive and that it can be removed alive by cutting open the belly of the deceased woman, there is no harm in that; because it leads to the preservation of a protected soul.
The presenter:
What Allah willed.
The Shaykh:
Yes, and it does not result in significant harm to the deceased body. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good,
The questioner:
Who refused after that, Shaykh? If it is established by one or more doctors that the fetus in the belly of the deceased woman is alive, and that by performing an operation the fetus can be removed alive, and then the woman's guardian refuses, whether he is a husband, father, brother, or similar, what is the ruling on this refusal?
The Shaykh:
This is referred to the specialists. If they determine that the fetus is alive and that if it is hastened to be removed, its life will be saved by that, then the operation is performed.
The questioner:
And who refused?
The Shaykh:
The refusal is taken based on the opinion of the other guardians who come after him. It may be that the woman has more than one guardian, so it is referred to the others.
The questioner:
Allah, may Allah reward you with good and do you well. If the situation is as mentioned, does it benefit, Shaykh Salih, to perform the operation if the doctor is trustworthy and confident that the fetus will come out alive?
The Shaykh:
With the agreement of the opposing guardian.
The presenter:
Welcome, and may Allah reward you.
The Shaykh:
And the guardian of the woman is the one who has the right to dispute.
The presenter:
Better than the other.
The Shaykh:
And it is necessary to be certain in these matters and not to be hasty. Yes.
Umm 'Umar says: Honorable Shaykh, my father passed away twenty-five years ago. Two years before his death, my aunt, his first wife, died while pregnant in her ninth month. The doctor said the fetus was alive and that we could perform a cesarean section to save it. My father refused, saying the fetus was not more valuable than its mother, and he was confused about who would raise it. At the same time, he left it as it was because he did not know that it was not permissible. Is my father sinful for that, and is he considered to have caused the killing of a soul? If so, what is the expiation we should pay on his behalf so that he is not punished in his grave? The reason we delayed asking is that we did not know the ruling. Also, we were in pain in that situation, and we were young. May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh:
Your father owes nothing in this matter, because it has not been established that the fetus died due to the failure to perform the operation to remove it. The operation might have been performed, and the fetus might have come out dead, or it might have died during the procedure. It has not been established that its death was caused by not performing the operation. Furthermore, performing such an operation requires the confirmation of trustworthy doctors who certify that the fetus is alive and that removing it will not harm the mother, among other conditions. Therefore, your father owes nothing in this; because the causality in the fetus's death was not established. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good and do you good.
The questioner:
In the previous question, Shaykh Salih, if the doctor mentions that the fetus is alive in the belly of a deceased woman, and that by performing a cesarean section it can be removed alive, by the will of Allah, is the operation performed in that case or not?
The Shaykh:
If the mother is dead, and the doctor determines that the fetus is alive and that it can be removed alive by cutting open the belly of the deceased woman, there is no harm in that; because it leads to the preservation of a protected soul.
The presenter:
What Allah willed.
The Shaykh:
Yes, and it does not result in significant harm to the deceased body. Yes.
The presenter:
May Allah reward you with good,
The questioner:
Who refused after that, Shaykh? If it is established by one or more doctors that the fetus in the belly of the deceased woman is alive, and that by performing an operation the fetus can be removed alive, and then the woman's guardian refuses, whether he is a husband, father, brother, or similar, what is the ruling on this refusal?
The Shaykh:
This is referred to the specialists. If they determine that the fetus is alive and that if it is hastened to be removed, its life will be saved by that, then the operation is performed.
The questioner:
And who refused?
The Shaykh:
The refusal is taken based on the opinion of the other guardians who come after him. It may be that the woman has more than one guardian, so it is referred to the others.
The questioner:
Allah, may Allah reward you with good and do you well. If the situation is as mentioned, does it benefit, Shaykh Salih, to perform the operation if the doctor is trustworthy and confident that the fetus will come out alive?
The Shaykh:
With the agreement of the opposing guardian.
The presenter:
Welcome, and may Allah reward you.
The Shaykh:
And the guardian of the woman is the one who has the right to dispute.
The presenter:
Better than the other.
The Shaykh:
And it is necessary to be certain in these matters and not to be hasty. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، توفيت امرأة وهي حامل في شهرها التاسع، فقال الطبيب إن الجنين حي، فرفض زوجها إخراجه فهل يأثم؟ الفوزان — youtube.com
