She gave the price of the hady to a man with her to slaughter it, but he forgot, and after a few days he remembered and returned the money to her. What is her obligation?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
What is the ruling for a woman who performed the obligatory Hajj last year and gave the money for the hady to a man among her companions so that he would collect the money and slaughter it? However, he forgot and did not include her name in the list he wrote at the time of slaughter. After returning to Makkah, she remembered this a few days after Mina. She remembered it, and he returned the money to her. She asked a Shaykh in a mosque near the Haram, and he told her to fast for ten days. She fasted after returning to her home country. Has the obligation been lifted from her? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Her obligation is that she slaughter the animal, even if it is after the days of Tashreeq, and this falls under the category of taking possession. If the man did not slaughter on her behalf and returned her money, it is obligatory for her to buy a sacrificial animal and slaughter it in Makkah when she goes to Makkah, or to send someone to buy a sacrificial animal and slaughter it in Makkah. This would be making up the missed act. Fasting is not sufficient for her as long as she is able to slaughter, even if it is after the completion of Hajj. She slaughters it as a make-up. Yes. May Allah reward you with good, and may He do you well.
What is the ruling for a woman who performed the obligatory Hajj last year and gave the money for the hady to a man among her companions so that he would collect the money and slaughter it? However, he forgot and did not include her name in the list he wrote at the time of slaughter. After returning to Makkah, she remembered this a few days after Mina. She remembered it, and he returned the money to her. She asked a Shaykh in a mosque near the Haram, and he told her to fast for ten days. She fasted after returning to her home country. Has the obligation been lifted from her? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Her obligation is that she slaughter the animal, even if it is after the days of Tashreeq, and this falls under the category of taking possession. If the man did not slaughter on her behalf and returned her money, it is obligatory for her to buy a sacrificial animal and slaughter it in Makkah when she goes to Makkah, or to send someone to buy a sacrificial animal and slaughter it in Makkah. This would be making up the missed act. Fasting is not sufficient for her as long as she is able to slaughter, even if it is after the completion of Hajj. She slaughters it as a make-up. Yes. May Allah reward you with good, and may He do you well.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، اعطت ثمن الهدي لرجل معها ليذبحه لكنه نسي وبعد أيام تذكر وأعاد ثمنه لها فماذا عليها؟ شيخ صالح الفوزان — youtube.com
