What is better for a non-resident: Tawaf or prayer?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : He asks: What is better for a non-resident when he visits Makkah: Tawaf or prayer, and which is longer?
Answer : And what is the authenticity of the narrations indicating that whoever performs fifty Tawafs returns from his sins as if he were born on the day his mother gave birth to him? I ask the scholars for information. They say that for a non-resident, it is better not to perform Tawaf because his stay is short, and he can catch up on the prayer in his country. The correct view is that a person should look at what is best for his heart. It is likely that there is crowding in Tawaf, and the person gets tired and does not become humble, whereas in prayer, if he is in a corner of the Haram, he becomes more humble. So here we say prayer is better. The important thing is that a person looks at what is most beneficial for him.
Answer : And what is the authenticity of the narrations indicating that whoever performs fifty Tawafs returns from his sins as if he were born on the day his mother gave birth to him? I ask the scholars for information. They say that for a non-resident, it is better not to perform Tawaf because his stay is short, and he can catch up on the prayer in his country. The correct view is that a person should look at what is best for his heart. It is likely that there is crowding in Tawaf, and the person gets tired and does not become humble, whereas in prayer, if he is in a corner of the Haram, he becomes more humble. So here we say prayer is better. The important thing is that a person looks at what is most beneficial for him.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 326 - 332 ما هو الأفضل بالنسبة للأفقي إذا زار مكة الطواف أو الصلاة وما صحة الآثار الدالة على أن... — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
