Does every act of worship that requires the remembrance of Allah also require the remembrance of the Messenger?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Does every act of worship that requires the remembrance of Allah also require the remembrance of the Messenger?
Answer : No, absolutely not. Slaughtering, slaughtering, slaughtering, and ablution, many things, the glorification in prayer and after prayer, the takbir on the two festivals, but they brought up a doubt. This is called qiyas al-shabah (analogical reasoning based on similarity), which is when a branch is in doubt between two roots, so it is attached to the one it most resembles. And this qiyas that we mentioned is not valid, because the majority of cases are that it is not obligatory to mention the Messenger along with the mention of Allah.
Answer : No, absolutely not. Slaughtering, slaughtering, slaughtering, and ablution, many things, the glorification in prayer and after prayer, the takbir on the two festivals, but they brought up a doubt. This is called qiyas al-shabah (analogical reasoning based on similarity), which is when a branch is in doubt between two roots, so it is attached to the one it most resembles. And this qiyas that we mentioned is not valid, because the majority of cases are that it is not obligatory to mention the Messenger along with the mention of Allah.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1530 - هل كل عبادة افتقرت إلى ذكر الله تفتقر إلى ذكر الرسول؟ ابن عثيمين — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.
