I swore an oath of divorce that I would not bring any of the grains from my farm into my house, but they sold the grains and gave my family the money. What is the ruling on my oath?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you with good and do you well. A message was sent by one of the brothers who says: I am an Egyptian citizen residing in the Kingdom. My name is 'Atiyyah Habib al-Sayyid. I ask: When I was in Egypt, a dispute arose between me and my father over a piece of land. This land belongs to me, and while I was traveling, my father cultivated it. He did not give my children any of the types of grains from it. A dispute arose between us that led me to swear an oath of divorce that I would not bring these grains into my house. The land was planted with rice, and my children and I were in need of it. I traveled, and my wife learned of what had happened. When the time for harvest came, my father insisted on giving the wife some of the rice, but she refused. So my father sold my share of the rice and gave her the money. Does this constitute breaking my oath of divorce? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Yes. If you swore by divorce or by an oath by Allah that you would not take this rice, and your intention was to refrain from taking it and benefiting from it, then this includes its value. If he sold it and gave you the value, or gave your wife the value and you approved of that, then this necessitates breaking the oath you swore. This is because the oath is on the thing itself and on its value, because the value is a substitute for it. Yes.
May Allah reward you with good and do you well. A message was sent by one of the brothers who says: I am an Egyptian citizen residing in the Kingdom. My name is 'Atiyyah Habib al-Sayyid. I ask: When I was in Egypt, a dispute arose between me and my father over a piece of land. This land belongs to me, and while I was traveling, my father cultivated it. He did not give my children any of the types of grains from it. A dispute arose between us that led me to swear an oath of divorce that I would not bring these grains into my house. The land was planted with rice, and my children and I were in need of it. I traveled, and my wife learned of what had happened. When the time for harvest came, my father insisted on giving the wife some of the rice, but she refused. So my father sold my share of the rice and gave her the money. Does this constitute breaking my oath of divorce? May Allah reward you with good.
Answer:
Yes. If you swore by divorce or by an oath by Allah that you would not take this rice, and your intention was to refrain from taking it and benefiting from it, then this includes its value. If he sold it and gave you the value, or gave your wife the value and you approved of that, then this necessitates breaking the oath you swore. This is because the oath is on the thing itself and on its value, because the value is a substitute for it. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، حلفت يمين الطلاق ألا يدخل شيئا من حبوب مزرعتي إلى بيتي فباعوا الحبوب وأعطوا أهلي المال فما حكم حلفي؟ — youtube.com
