What is the meaning of the statement of the Imam al-Mujaddid (may Allah have mercy on him): that most of what is in al-Muntaha and al-Iqna' is contrary to the explicit texts of Imam Ahmad?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
He says (may Allah preserve you): What is the meaning of the statement of the Imam al-Mujaddid (may Allah have mercy on him) that most of what is in al-Muntaha and al-Iqna' is contrary to the explicit texts of Imam Ahmad?
Answer:
It is either different interpretations, or different derivations, or rather, it is not from the words of Imam Ahmad. Its meaning is that it is invalid; its meaning is that it is not from the words of Imam Ahmad, but rather it is from the words of the companions (scholars) who derived it, or that they held to different interpretations. Its meaning is invalidity.
He says (may Allah preserve you): What is the meaning of the statement of the Imam al-Mujaddid (may Allah have mercy on him) that most of what is in al-Muntaha and al-Iqna' is contrary to the explicit texts of Imam Ahmad?
Answer:
It is either different interpretations, or different derivations, or rather, it is not from the words of Imam Ahmad. Its meaning is that it is invalid; its meaning is that it is not from the words of Imam Ahmad, but rather it is from the words of the companions (scholars) who derived it, or that they held to different interpretations. Its meaning is invalidity.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، [630 -3022] ما معنى قول الإمام المجدد: إن أكثر ما في المنتهى والإقناع مخالف للمنصوص عن الإمام أحمد؟ — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.