The Difference Between Hady and Udhiyah for the Pilgrim Performing Tamattu'

Question:
Our honorable Shaykh (may Allah preserve you), is it sufficient for the pilgrim performing tamattu' to offer the hady in place of the 'Id sacrifice? And does he intend with his hady that it be for himself and his family?

Answer:
No, the hady is for him alone, not for others. As for the 'Id sacrifice, the 'Id sacrifice is not the hady. The 'Id sacrifice is what is slaughtered on the day of 'Id or during the days of Tashriq in any location; that is the 'Id sacrifice. As for the hady, it is in Makkah; it is in Makkah or in Mina, or in the Haram; the fidyah is slaughtered in all the areas of the Haram, the fidyah for tamattu'. Yes.