What is the difference between classifying hadith into authentic and weak, and classifying them into authentic, good, and weak?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner: The hadith into authentic and weak. The second is the prostration of Umm al-Fadl, the wife of Shaykh al-Albani. Thanks to Allah for the blessing of tawhid (the oneness of Allah) and other fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence) issues. This session was recorded in Sha'ban, corresponding to the second month of the Hijri year.
The Shaykh: And upon you be peace and the mercy of Allah. The publisher, may Allah bless him. Because the truth is. For the sake of Abu Ahmad, meaning, that this question. Because it is being raised for the first time, so this requires that the answer also be given for the first time and clarified. So your statement that the old terminology was that they divided the hadith into authentic and weak. And the terminology that followed, and I do not say "hadith" for fear that it be understood as the hadith of the present age, but rather I say the terminology that came after that terminology, which is their saying "authentic, good, and weak," this, as I said earlier, is more precise in expression. But it is not just this precision. And here I say that for the first time I am mentioning this detail. The predecessors who divided the hadith into authentic and weak also did not address dividing the authentic into authentic, authentic widespread, authentic famous, and authentic mass-transmitted. Did this also come with that division or later? Yes, the latter. And without a doubt, this division, with its first part which you asked about and the other part which I added to it, is without a doubt much better than that generalization. And rulings depend on it. And these rulings were mentioned based on this detail established in the science of hadith terminology. They explained that rulings depend on it. For example, in the science of the types of hadith sciences, it is the differing hadiths. The differing hadiths. And some of the old hadith scholars wrote books under this exact title. The most famous of them, which is printed today and well-known and circulated, is *Mukhtalif al-Hadith* by Ibn Qutaybah. So in this science, they spoke, and the best I have seen speaking in it with brevity and condensed meaning is al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani in his famous treatise *Sharh al-Nukhba*, where he said: If two contradictory hadiths come from an acceptable category, it is obligatory to reconcile them by one of the many ways of reconciliation. If that is not possible, it is referred to weighing them against each other. Here the topic comes in: weighing them against each other is the second rank if reconciliation is not possible.
How is the weighing done? If a good hadith opposes an authentic one, the authentic is preferred over the good. If an authentic opposes a widespread one, the widespread is preferred. And likewise, if a famous one opposes a widespread or mass-transmitted one, the mass-transmitted is preferred over the famous and the widespread. Yes.
So practical aspects depend on this division. Then he said: If weighing is not possible, meaning it is a good against a good, an authentic against an authentic, and so on, then the abrogating and the abrogated are sought from them. If that is not possible, the matter is left to its expert. So this division is precise and practical things depend on it. This is regarding the first part of your question. What was the second part? I hope you will remind me of it.
The questioner: The second person, which is safer?
The Shaykh: I think he took the answer from what was clarified, is that not so? Which is safer? The safer is the detail, not the generalization.
The questioner: Shaykh, it is clear, but Shaykh, a small point like this. Shaykh, when a hadith is established, regardless of the degree of authenticity, meaning, do I know the degree of authenticity? When it is established, of course, we must follow it because it is established. But Shaykh, from the perspective of, meaning, from the perspective of, being attached to the people of desires, meaning, is the rank authentic or weak, meaning, like the middle of the back? So I say it is safer from this perspective in the methodology, except for the aspect of speech, which is in this.
The Shaykh: It is not clear. If you mean something other than what we answered.
The Shaykh: And upon you be peace and the mercy of Allah. The publisher, may Allah bless him. Because the truth is. For the sake of Abu Ahmad, meaning, that this question. Because it is being raised for the first time, so this requires that the answer also be given for the first time and clarified. So your statement that the old terminology was that they divided the hadith into authentic and weak. And the terminology that followed, and I do not say "hadith" for fear that it be understood as the hadith of the present age, but rather I say the terminology that came after that terminology, which is their saying "authentic, good, and weak," this, as I said earlier, is more precise in expression. But it is not just this precision. And here I say that for the first time I am mentioning this detail. The predecessors who divided the hadith into authentic and weak also did not address dividing the authentic into authentic, authentic widespread, authentic famous, and authentic mass-transmitted. Did this also come with that division or later? Yes, the latter. And without a doubt, this division, with its first part which you asked about and the other part which I added to it, is without a doubt much better than that generalization. And rulings depend on it. And these rulings were mentioned based on this detail established in the science of hadith terminology. They explained that rulings depend on it. For example, in the science of the types of hadith sciences, it is the differing hadiths. The differing hadiths. And some of the old hadith scholars wrote books under this exact title. The most famous of them, which is printed today and well-known and circulated, is *Mukhtalif al-Hadith* by Ibn Qutaybah. So in this science, they spoke, and the best I have seen speaking in it with brevity and condensed meaning is al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani in his famous treatise *Sharh al-Nukhba*, where he said: If two contradictory hadiths come from an acceptable category, it is obligatory to reconcile them by one of the many ways of reconciliation. If that is not possible, it is referred to weighing them against each other. Here the topic comes in: weighing them against each other is the second rank if reconciliation is not possible.
How is the weighing done? If a good hadith opposes an authentic one, the authentic is preferred over the good. If an authentic opposes a widespread one, the widespread is preferred. And likewise, if a famous one opposes a widespread or mass-transmitted one, the mass-transmitted is preferred over the famous and the widespread. Yes.
So practical aspects depend on this division. Then he said: If weighing is not possible, meaning it is a good against a good, an authentic against an authentic, and so on, then the abrogating and the abrogated are sought from them. If that is not possible, the matter is left to its expert. So this division is precise and practical things depend on it. This is regarding the first part of your question. What was the second part? I hope you will remind me of it.
The questioner: The second person, which is safer?
The Shaykh: I think he took the answer from what was clarified, is that not so? Which is safer? The safer is the detail, not the generalization.
The questioner: Shaykh, it is clear, but Shaykh, a small point like this. Shaykh, when a hadith is established, regardless of the degree of authenticity, meaning, do I know the degree of authenticity? When it is established, of course, we must follow it because it is established. But Shaykh, from the perspective of, meaning, from the perspective of, being attached to the people of desires, meaning, is the rank authentic or weak, meaning, like the middle of the back? So I say it is safer from this perspective in the methodology, except for the aspect of speech, which is in this.
The Shaykh: It is not clear. If you mean something other than what we answered.
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1096 — al-albany.com (1:35)
