The Ruling on Prostration of Gratitude for a Calamity and Wishing for It
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Peace be upon you. Well, I am the last one, meaning there is a scholar, our Shaykh, who holds that prostration of gratitude for a calamity is not prescribed. He sees the ranks of the patient, as Ibn al-Qayyim did with the ranks of the patient, and he holds that the greatest among them is the one who prostrates in gratitude to Allah the Exalted, or the one who gives thanks—he did not say prostrates, he said gives thanks to Allah for the calamity. So, it happened to our brother 'Aziz, may Allah preserve him, when the matter of the Qala'a occurred—I remember he prostrated. I do not know if he prostrated in gratitude, and Allah lightened it, and some people understood that he prostrated, meaning perhaps in gratitude for what he was afflicted with. In any case, in this sense, if a person prostrates in gratitude to Allah for something that befalls him, do you see this as prescribed or not prescribed? And [it] was not forgiven.
The Shaykh : Within the limits of what is deserved, it is not prescribed.
The questioner : There is no blame on him.
The Shaykh : Within the limits of what is deserved, it is not prescribed.
The questioner : There is no blame on him.
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1096 — al-albany.com (15:28)
