The ruling on taking an excess over the price of car repair after a settlement
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : There was a car accident between two cars. The one with the right agreed that he would repair it, or that the cost of the damage would be paid to him, so it was paid to him. This man took the money and did not repair his car, or he took, or rather gained, an excess from this amount.
The Shaykh : How is the excess?
The questioner : For example, a part costs less than the amount received from the one who caused the accident. What is the ruling on that?
The Shaykh : There is nothing wrong with it as long as they settled on this. Whether he repaired his car or did not repair it, or repaired it at a cost less than what was given to him, except if they agreed that whatever the cost is, I will pay it. But according to what I heard from you, the agreement was not like that.
The questioner : For example, a part cost one hundred dinars, yes.
The Shaykh : According to what I heard, there was no agreement, so the answer is what I heard. Yes.
The questioner : The other aspect, or to clarify: if they agreed that the part you hit, the light that you broke, for example, cost one hundred and a quarter of a hundred dinars, but when he bought it, he took a lower quality one for fifty dinars, so what happens to the remaining fifty?
The Shaykh : Here the agreement differs, my brother. Every question has an answer. This goes back to the scenario I mentioned where they did not agree on it.
The questioner : We did not agree.
The Shaykh : The ruling is the same. If they agreed that this part, what will it cost, you will pay me? And this is one hundred dinars, what will it cost, this is your right. In that case, he must return the remainder. But if they ended the settlement on this amount, whether the cost was less or more, the matter is finished.
The Shaykh : How is the excess?
The questioner : For example, a part costs less than the amount received from the one who caused the accident. What is the ruling on that?
The Shaykh : There is nothing wrong with it as long as they settled on this. Whether he repaired his car or did not repair it, or repaired it at a cost less than what was given to him, except if they agreed that whatever the cost is, I will pay it. But according to what I heard from you, the agreement was not like that.
The questioner : For example, a part cost one hundred dinars, yes.
The Shaykh : According to what I heard, there was no agreement, so the answer is what I heard. Yes.
The questioner : The other aspect, or to clarify: if they agreed that the part you hit, the light that you broke, for example, cost one hundred and a quarter of a hundred dinars, but when he bought it, he took a lower quality one for fifty dinars, so what happens to the remaining fifty?
The Shaykh : Here the agreement differs, my brother. Every question has an answer. This goes back to the scenario I mentioned where they did not agree on it.
The questioner : We did not agree.
The Shaykh : The ruling is the same. If they agreed that this part, what will it cost, you will pay me? And this is one hundred dinars, what will it cost, this is your right. In that case, he must return the remainder. But if they ended the settlement on this amount, whether the cost was less or more, the matter is finished.
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1096 — al-albany.com (37:59)
