The ruling on praying in a mosque that contains a grave, or in the qiblah of a mosque
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : In the name of Allah, and praise is due to Allah. Our Shaykh, may Allah reward you with good and bless you and your life. In these days, the affliction has spread to mosques that contain graves. This is a trial that confronts the employed imams and the young men who pray, who are keen to follow the Sunnah and keen to stay away from such mosques.
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : How wonderful it would be if you would be generous with us by explaining the ruling on these mosques. When do we say that the grave prevents prayer, and when do we say that it is outside the mosque and does not prevent prayer? May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh : Praise is due to Allah, and may blessings and peace be upon the Messenger of Allah. One who follows the hadiths narrated from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), which all agree on the emphatic prohibition of building mosques over graves, derives from them that the grave which prevents prayer in a mosque built over it is the one that is within the circle of what is called a mosque. This means that there is no difference between what is inside the mosque or what is outside, meaning between what is customarily called the sacred precinct or the courtyard of the sacred precinct. Naturally, as you know, there is no sacred precinct except in the Prophet’s Mosque and the Sacred Mosque. So, if the mosque’s courtyard is inside the mosque, and this naturally only happens if the courtyard is within the mosque’s wall, then it is part of it. However, if the courtyard is open and not part of the mosque, then if the grave is in this courtyard, prayer inside the mosque is permissible and there is nothing wrong with it. This is the opposite of the case where the grave is in the external part of the mosque, and this external section is walled and attached to the mosque. This is the first scenario.
The other scenario, which Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) explained, is when there is a grave in the qiblah of the mosque. This grave, although it is outside the mosque, prevents prayer in this mosque because it is in the qiblah of the mosque. This is unlike the case where the grave is outside the mosque to the right, left, or behind, in which case prayer in this mosque is permissible. This is the opposite of the case where the grave is in the qiblah of the mosque. In this scenario, Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) holds that it should be obligatory to build a wall between the grave and the qiblah wall of the mosque. This question was sent to me two or three days ago by phone from some of our Egyptian brothers in the Ghor. He asked me about a grave in the qiblah of the mosque, but it is separated by a wall. I wanted to seek clarification from him. After some back and forth, it became clear when I asked him if a person can pass between the two walls, i.e., the qiblah wall of the mosque and the northern wall of the grave. He answered affirmatively that it is possible. So I said at that time that the prayer in this mosque is valid and there is nothing wrong with it. However, we say:
Imam Ahmad’s request that there be another wall separating the qiblah wall of the mosque from the grave is, in reality, a matter of blocking the means to harm and being cautious in the religion of Allah the Exalted and Majestic. Otherwise, the grave is outside the mosque, and the mosque is safe from any violation in praying in it, because the hadiths we referred to all focus on the prohibition of building a mosque over a grave. And if the grave is outside the mosque, it is not accurate to say that this mosque was built over a grave. So Imam Ahmad’s suggestion that there be a separating wall between the qiblah wall of the mosque and the wall of the grave is a matter of caution. Accordingly, we have two scenarios: one where the grave is in the mosque, and it does not matter if it is in the qiblah of the mosque, the north, the west, or the east of the mosque; all of this prevents prayer in the mosque as long as it is accurate to say that it was built over a grave. This is unlike what I mentioned earlier, explaining that if the grave is in a courtyard close to the mosque, and this courtyard has not been incorporated into the mosque by being walled and attached to it, then this does not harm. This is the opposite of what we mentioned earlier regarding the case where the grave is in the qiblah of the mosque and outside the mosque. In this case, according to the opinion of Imam Ahmad, it is necessary, as a precaution,
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : How wonderful it would be if you would be generous with us by explaining the ruling on these mosques. When do we say that the grave prevents prayer, and when do we say that it is outside the mosque and does not prevent prayer? May Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh : Praise is due to Allah, and may blessings and peace be upon the Messenger of Allah. One who follows the hadiths narrated from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), which all agree on the emphatic prohibition of building mosques over graves, derives from them that the grave which prevents prayer in a mosque built over it is the one that is within the circle of what is called a mosque. This means that there is no difference between what is inside the mosque or what is outside, meaning between what is customarily called the sacred precinct or the courtyard of the sacred precinct. Naturally, as you know, there is no sacred precinct except in the Prophet’s Mosque and the Sacred Mosque. So, if the mosque’s courtyard is inside the mosque, and this naturally only happens if the courtyard is within the mosque’s wall, then it is part of it. However, if the courtyard is open and not part of the mosque, then if the grave is in this courtyard, prayer inside the mosque is permissible and there is nothing wrong with it. This is the opposite of the case where the grave is in the external part of the mosque, and this external section is walled and attached to the mosque. This is the first scenario.
The other scenario, which Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) explained, is when there is a grave in the qiblah of the mosque. This grave, although it is outside the mosque, prevents prayer in this mosque because it is in the qiblah of the mosque. This is unlike the case where the grave is outside the mosque to the right, left, or behind, in which case prayer in this mosque is permissible. This is the opposite of the case where the grave is in the qiblah of the mosque. In this scenario, Imam Ahmad (may Allah have mercy on him) holds that it should be obligatory to build a wall between the grave and the qiblah wall of the mosque. This question was sent to me two or three days ago by phone from some of our Egyptian brothers in the Ghor. He asked me about a grave in the qiblah of the mosque, but it is separated by a wall. I wanted to seek clarification from him. After some back and forth, it became clear when I asked him if a person can pass between the two walls, i.e., the qiblah wall of the mosque and the northern wall of the grave. He answered affirmatively that it is possible. So I said at that time that the prayer in this mosque is valid and there is nothing wrong with it. However, we say:
Imam Ahmad’s request that there be another wall separating the qiblah wall of the mosque from the grave is, in reality, a matter of blocking the means to harm and being cautious in the religion of Allah the Exalted and Majestic. Otherwise, the grave is outside the mosque, and the mosque is safe from any violation in praying in it, because the hadiths we referred to all focus on the prohibition of building a mosque over a grave. And if the grave is outside the mosque, it is not accurate to say that this mosque was built over a grave. So Imam Ahmad’s suggestion that there be a separating wall between the qiblah wall of the mosque and the wall of the grave is a matter of caution. Accordingly, we have two scenarios: one where the grave is in the mosque, and it does not matter if it is in the qiblah of the mosque, the north, the west, or the east of the mosque; all of this prevents prayer in the mosque as long as it is accurate to say that it was built over a grave. This is unlike what I mentioned earlier, explaining that if the grave is in a courtyard close to the mosque, and this courtyard has not been incorporated into the mosque by being walled and attached to it, then this does not harm. This is the opposite of what we mentioned earlier regarding the case where the grave is in the qiblah of the mosque and outside the mosque. In this case, according to the opinion of Imam Ahmad, it is necessary, as a precaution,
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1100 — al-albany.com (1:56)
