Is it permissible to advise a mujahid to refrain from participating in a specific battle?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is it permissible for us, in the eyes of the Shari'ah, my dear brother, if one of the brothers inquires, to ask him not to participate with them? Is it incumbent upon us in this matter to tell him, "Do not go to such-and-such a battle, do not go to such-and-such a front, go to another one, or go to that one, or do such-and-such"?
The Shaykh: By Allah, it is difficult for me to give a definitive answer on this matter. Because, in truth, I do not know whether this statement will be beneficial or harmful. The witness sees what the absent one does not see. As for the name al-Farouq, it is established as "the one who distinguishes." From al-Farouq, from 'Umar, from al-Farouq, and by Allah, I do not remember. Please proceed. As for the fact that Satan flees from him and takes a path other than his, that is established. As for whether he distinguishes between truth and falsehood, I do not know.
The Shaykh: By Allah, it is difficult for me to give a definitive answer on this matter. Because, in truth, I do not know whether this statement will be beneficial or harmful. The witness sees what the absent one does not see. As for the name al-Farouq, it is established as "the one who distinguishes." From al-Farouq, from 'Umar, from al-Farouq, and by Allah, I do not remember. Please proceed. As for the fact that Satan flees from him and takes a path other than his, that is established. As for whether he distinguishes between truth and falsehood, I do not know.
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1103 — al-albany.com (23:26)
