When is the title of Imam applied to a person?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner: O our dear professor, who is it permissible to call an Imam, or what are the qualities that allow us to say that so-and-so is an Imam? I mean, "Imam So-and-so."
The Shaykh: Imam So-and-so.
The questioner: Applying this title to some people.
The Shaykh: You mean an Imam in knowledge, not an Imam in prayer, right?
The questioner: So he is not an Imam.
The Shaykh: If he is not.
The questioner: An Imam in prayer or in leading people. For example, some of our brothers say, for instance, "Imam Shaykh Abdullah 'Azzam," giving him the title of Imam. And some say "Imam," like the Imam of the City of Migration, Imam Malik (may Allah be pleased with him). So when is Hasan al-Banna an Imam? Yes, al-Hudaybi is an Imam. When is it permissible for us to call someone an Imam?
The Shaykh: By Allah, this is a sensitive and precise matter. First, the issue is relative. This reminds me of a similar question: Who is called a hadith master (muhaddith) of his time? One who memorizes how many thousand questions?
Another questioner: More than that, and a hundred thousand.
The Shaykh: In that case, there is no hadith master after them. So I want to say that the issue is relative. As the land becomes empty of hadith masters, the definition of the name "muhaddith" becomes more lenient. For example, people call me a hadith master, but among the hadith masters, I am not a hadith master. The only thing is that the old Arabic proverb was true of us: "The crows in our land are startled by my time." I went to Egypt, and in Egypt, they hold festivals and celebrations for occasions and non-occasions. I was truly surprised. The presenter, a famous man and orator who has since passed away, introduced me.
Another questioner: Ahmad ibn al-Ghazi.
The Shaykh: I almost melted with shame when I heard him say "Imam So-and-so." So this word, like that word, meaning "Imam" and "Muhaddith," and the word before that, "Shahid" (martyr), and the one before that, "Hajj" (pilgrim), they all apply to each other. We do not believe that there are among us people who truly deserve to be called "Imam of the Muslims." Why? Because we all know that the first thing that comes to mind with the word "Imam" is the Imam of the Muslims in general, and that is only for the Muslim ruler who is, in the custom of Muslims, the Caliph.
Today the earth is empty of its thrones; there is no Caliph in it. Therefore, there is no Imam, no Imam of the Muslims. So the matter seems difficult from one side, but as it is said, "The crisis intensifies so that it may be resolved." So according to your situation, today in the mosques there are Imams who lead people in prayer but do not perform the prayer well, and incidents occur where they do not handle them well, but he is the Imam of the mosque. So if the issue becomes relative, if we want to use the word "Imam" in its absolute sense, it is missing because the Imam of the Muslims does not exist today, unfortunately. So what comes below that? What comes below that? A ruler in some lands, a decisive scholar who rules by Islam, that is the Imam of the Muslims. But the Imam of the Muslims in general, no. The Imam of the Muslims in this village, in this town, in this capital, in this emirate, in this state, and so on. And judge accordingly.
Finally, I say we must stay away from all these terms because they are also not from the methodology of the righteous Salaf. Do you know of any scholar among the scholars of the Companions, the Successors, and those after them, including the Imams who were independent jurists, who were called "Imam So-and-so" in their time? We do not know of this at all. In reality, I am annoyed now, especially since this used to appear in the past but now it is frequent. You might hear me on the radio saying "Prince So-and-so came, traveled from such-and-such, and came to the town, and Prince So-and-so and Prince So-and-so and His Highness Prince So-and-so and His Highness Prince So-and-so came out to welcome him." All of this is Western usage, intended to inflate the souls and thereby destroy them with these titles. What does that witness say? "It speaks of swelling, the image of the lion."
Another questioner: My professor, perhaps your election is above.
The Shaykh: Before, before, what does it say? Do you know this poem? It is not like this?
Another questioner: In a place other than its place, like a cat speaking of swelling, another time.
The Shaykh: Asadi, empty titles, of this sort, using the word of majesty for Muslim kings, all of this is a departure from the guidance of the righteous Salaf entirely. But, woe to you, some evil is worse than some. So I do not see it permissible to use the word "Imam" other than in the customary meaning known today. It is permissible for a man who is not good at praying like the people to lead the people in the mosque; he is the Imam of this mosque. And we used to understand the Imam of the mosque to mean a man who is a scholar, a righteous man, an elderly man. But now, if politics requires that the Imam be clever and not holding fast to his religion, for what reason? So that they can contain him easily.
He is an Imam, but in any case, he is an Imam. As for using the word "Imam" like "Imam Muhammad 'Abduh," for example, I do not agree with that. Why? As for the scholars of al-Azhar, he was a call for reform, but he brought corruption because he opened the door to renewal in al-Azhar, and al-Azhar turned into a university among the universities, without the distinctive Islamic scientific appearance that existed before, praise be to Allah. They say, "Mention the name of Allah." Fine. The word "Shaykh" falls under this. Our brother Hasan reminds me of this. A man calls me on the phone, "Peace be upon you," and I say, "And upon you peace." He asks, "Question, so-and-so, I say to him, 'Who are you?'" He says, "Shaykh so-and-so." I say to him, "Are you a Shaykh?" The poor man is confused. I say to him, "My brother, the word Shaykh has two meanings: either you are a Shaykh like the story of the Makhitir, who reached eighty, or you are a Shaykh who is a noble scholar. So, are you like this or like that?" He says, "Neither this nor that." If he is a Shaykh, why are you calling yourself a Shaykh? So, think about it: now everyone who let his beard grow, what did he become? A Shaykh, may Allah protect us, 'Abdullah. Perhaps. I do not know tonight or other than tonight, I heard a man say to me, "What did he say?" I do not know. "Honorable Shaykh, is Al-Albani present?" Yes, I said to him, "I am Muhammad." So, Honorable Shaykh, can you say to a man who is not Honorable Shaykh? He will rebuke you and say to you, "You do not honor knowledge and scholars," and so on. These are the outer layers, Professor, they claimed, but they are the essence, they are what purify the souls and educate them.
Another questioner : ...forty.
The Shaykh: Yes, no, it is more eloquent. He is forty, perhaps he cannot digest it. The important thing is, or you are a Shaykh who is a noble scholar, meaning, so are you like this or like that? He says, "Neither this nor that." If he is a Shaykh, why are you calling yourself a Shaykh? So, think about it: now everyone who let his beard grow, what did he become? A Shaykh, may Allah protect us, 'Abdullah. Perhaps. I do not know tonight or other than tonight, I heard a man say to me, "What did he say?" I do not know. "Honorable Shaykh, is Al-Albani present?" Yes, I said to him, "I am Muhammad." So, Honorable Shaykh, can you say to a man who is not Honorable Shaykh? He will rebuke you and say to you, "You do not honor knowledge and scholars," and so on. These are the outer layers, Professor, they claimed, but they are the essence, they are what purify the souls and educate them.
The presenter : Our Shaykh, the specialist, *mukhtar* is also the word *mukhtar*.
The Shaykh : *Mukhtar*, why?
The presenter : *Mukhtari*, meaning he wants to invent himself in the eyes of people, like that.
The Shaykh : You are welcome.
The questioner : We ask you to excuse us, because it is...
The Shaykh : And we wish you a purposeful journey.
The questioner : Allah.
The Shaykh : And may you remember us with good there, and perhaps you will call us by phone so that we can be reassured about you.
The questioner : May Allah preserve you, may Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh : Welcome, welcome, and greetings. Thank you, thank you.
The Shaykh: Imam So-and-so.
The questioner: Applying this title to some people.
The Shaykh: You mean an Imam in knowledge, not an Imam in prayer, right?
The questioner: So he is not an Imam.
The Shaykh: If he is not.
The questioner: An Imam in prayer or in leading people. For example, some of our brothers say, for instance, "Imam Shaykh Abdullah 'Azzam," giving him the title of Imam. And some say "Imam," like the Imam of the City of Migration, Imam Malik (may Allah be pleased with him). So when is Hasan al-Banna an Imam? Yes, al-Hudaybi is an Imam. When is it permissible for us to call someone an Imam?
The Shaykh: By Allah, this is a sensitive and precise matter. First, the issue is relative. This reminds me of a similar question: Who is called a hadith master (muhaddith) of his time? One who memorizes how many thousand questions?
Another questioner: More than that, and a hundred thousand.
The Shaykh: In that case, there is no hadith master after them. So I want to say that the issue is relative. As the land becomes empty of hadith masters, the definition of the name "muhaddith" becomes more lenient. For example, people call me a hadith master, but among the hadith masters, I am not a hadith master. The only thing is that the old Arabic proverb was true of us: "The crows in our land are startled by my time." I went to Egypt, and in Egypt, they hold festivals and celebrations for occasions and non-occasions. I was truly surprised. The presenter, a famous man and orator who has since passed away, introduced me.
Another questioner: Ahmad ibn al-Ghazi.
The Shaykh: I almost melted with shame when I heard him say "Imam So-and-so." So this word, like that word, meaning "Imam" and "Muhaddith," and the word before that, "Shahid" (martyr), and the one before that, "Hajj" (pilgrim), they all apply to each other. We do not believe that there are among us people who truly deserve to be called "Imam of the Muslims." Why? Because we all know that the first thing that comes to mind with the word "Imam" is the Imam of the Muslims in general, and that is only for the Muslim ruler who is, in the custom of Muslims, the Caliph.
Today the earth is empty of its thrones; there is no Caliph in it. Therefore, there is no Imam, no Imam of the Muslims. So the matter seems difficult from one side, but as it is said, "The crisis intensifies so that it may be resolved." So according to your situation, today in the mosques there are Imams who lead people in prayer but do not perform the prayer well, and incidents occur where they do not handle them well, but he is the Imam of the mosque. So if the issue becomes relative, if we want to use the word "Imam" in its absolute sense, it is missing because the Imam of the Muslims does not exist today, unfortunately. So what comes below that? What comes below that? A ruler in some lands, a decisive scholar who rules by Islam, that is the Imam of the Muslims. But the Imam of the Muslims in general, no. The Imam of the Muslims in this village, in this town, in this capital, in this emirate, in this state, and so on. And judge accordingly.
Finally, I say we must stay away from all these terms because they are also not from the methodology of the righteous Salaf. Do you know of any scholar among the scholars of the Companions, the Successors, and those after them, including the Imams who were independent jurists, who were called "Imam So-and-so" in their time? We do not know of this at all. In reality, I am annoyed now, especially since this used to appear in the past but now it is frequent. You might hear me on the radio saying "Prince So-and-so came, traveled from such-and-such, and came to the town, and Prince So-and-so and Prince So-and-so and His Highness Prince So-and-so and His Highness Prince So-and-so came out to welcome him." All of this is Western usage, intended to inflate the souls and thereby destroy them with these titles. What does that witness say? "It speaks of swelling, the image of the lion."
Another questioner: My professor, perhaps your election is above.
The Shaykh: Before, before, what does it say? Do you know this poem? It is not like this?
Another questioner: In a place other than its place, like a cat speaking of swelling, another time.
The Shaykh: Asadi, empty titles, of this sort, using the word of majesty for Muslim kings, all of this is a departure from the guidance of the righteous Salaf entirely. But, woe to you, some evil is worse than some. So I do not see it permissible to use the word "Imam" other than in the customary meaning known today. It is permissible for a man who is not good at praying like the people to lead the people in the mosque; he is the Imam of this mosque. And we used to understand the Imam of the mosque to mean a man who is a scholar, a righteous man, an elderly man. But now, if politics requires that the Imam be clever and not holding fast to his religion, for what reason? So that they can contain him easily.
He is an Imam, but in any case, he is an Imam. As for using the word "Imam" like "Imam Muhammad 'Abduh," for example, I do not agree with that. Why? As for the scholars of al-Azhar, he was a call for reform, but he brought corruption because he opened the door to renewal in al-Azhar, and al-Azhar turned into a university among the universities, without the distinctive Islamic scientific appearance that existed before, praise be to Allah. They say, "Mention the name of Allah." Fine. The word "Shaykh" falls under this. Our brother Hasan reminds me of this. A man calls me on the phone, "Peace be upon you," and I say, "And upon you peace." He asks, "Question, so-and-so, I say to him, 'Who are you?'" He says, "Shaykh so-and-so." I say to him, "Are you a Shaykh?" The poor man is confused. I say to him, "My brother, the word Shaykh has two meanings: either you are a Shaykh like the story of the Makhitir, who reached eighty, or you are a Shaykh who is a noble scholar. So, are you like this or like that?" He says, "Neither this nor that." If he is a Shaykh, why are you calling yourself a Shaykh? So, think about it: now everyone who let his beard grow, what did he become? A Shaykh, may Allah protect us, 'Abdullah. Perhaps. I do not know tonight or other than tonight, I heard a man say to me, "What did he say?" I do not know. "Honorable Shaykh, is Al-Albani present?" Yes, I said to him, "I am Muhammad." So, Honorable Shaykh, can you say to a man who is not Honorable Shaykh? He will rebuke you and say to you, "You do not honor knowledge and scholars," and so on. These are the outer layers, Professor, they claimed, but they are the essence, they are what purify the souls and educate them.
Another questioner : ...forty.
The Shaykh: Yes, no, it is more eloquent. He is forty, perhaps he cannot digest it. The important thing is, or you are a Shaykh who is a noble scholar, meaning, so are you like this or like that? He says, "Neither this nor that." If he is a Shaykh, why are you calling yourself a Shaykh? So, think about it: now everyone who let his beard grow, what did he become? A Shaykh, may Allah protect us, 'Abdullah. Perhaps. I do not know tonight or other than tonight, I heard a man say to me, "What did he say?" I do not know. "Honorable Shaykh, is Al-Albani present?" Yes, I said to him, "I am Muhammad." So, Honorable Shaykh, can you say to a man who is not Honorable Shaykh? He will rebuke you and say to you, "You do not honor knowledge and scholars," and so on. These are the outer layers, Professor, they claimed, but they are the essence, they are what purify the souls and educate them.
The presenter : Our Shaykh, the specialist, *mukhtar* is also the word *mukhtar*.
The Shaykh : *Mukhtar*, why?
The presenter : *Mukhtari*, meaning he wants to invent himself in the eyes of people, like that.
The Shaykh : You are welcome.
The questioner : We ask you to excuse us, because it is...
The Shaykh : And we wish you a purposeful journey.
The questioner : Allah.
The Shaykh : And may you remember us with good there, and perhaps you will call us by phone so that we can be reassured about you.
The questioner : May Allah preserve you, may Allah reward you with good.
The Shaykh : Welcome, welcome, and greetings. Thank you, thank you.
Source
سلسلة الهدى والنور، الشريط 1103 — al-albany.com (57:30)
