The ruling on the hadith regarding the Surahs of the Prophets with a monk
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you. Honorable Shaykh, he says: What is the ruling on the hadith narrated by Abu Nu'aym regarding the Surahs of the Prophets, which were with a monk, and which Quraysh showed to the Muslims? How do we deal with them, given that the Surahs are forbidden and their authenticity is very weak?
Answer:
This is a specific case. This falls under a specific category; it is a particular matter. This and that were with a monk, not with the Muslims. This was with a monk, a Christian, not with the Muslims. Yes.
May Allah reward you. Honorable Shaykh, he says: What is the ruling on the hadith narrated by Abu Nu'aym regarding the Surahs of the Prophets, which were with a monk, and which Quraysh showed to the Muslims? How do we deal with them, given that the Surahs are forbidden and their authenticity is very weak?
Answer:
This is a specific case. This falls under a specific category; it is a particular matter. This and that were with a monk, not with the Muslims. This was with a monk, a Christian, not with the Muslims. Yes.
Source
صور الأنبياء التي كانت عند راهب — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.