The ruling on the one who does not condemn what is wrong in his heart
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
May Allah reward you. The Honorable Shaykh says: Is the one who does not denounce what is wrong, neither with his hand, nor with his tongue, nor with his heart, a hypocrite and a wicked person, with no faith beyond that? Is there a hadith that was transmitted?
Answer:
Yes, it is the apparent meaning of the hadith. The one who has faith in his heart denounces what is wrong, even if only with his heart. As for the one who does not denounce what is wrong, he has no faith in his heart; he has no faith in his heart. If things are equal in his estimation, that is evidence that he has no faith, even if it were a weak faith, like a grain of mustard seed. Therefore, the scholars say: He is destroyed who does not denounce what is wrong with his heart. This is the closest of the stages. Yes.
May Allah reward you. The Honorable Shaykh says: Is the one who does not denounce what is wrong, neither with his hand, nor with his tongue, nor with his heart, a hypocrite and a wicked person, with no faith beyond that? Is there a hadith that was transmitted?
Answer:
Yes, it is the apparent meaning of the hadith. The one who has faith in his heart denounces what is wrong, even if only with his heart. As for the one who does not denounce what is wrong, he has no faith in his heart; he has no faith in his heart. If things are equal in his estimation, that is evidence that he has no faith, even if it were a weak faith, like a grain of mustard seed. Therefore, the scholars say: He is destroyed who does not denounce what is wrong with his heart. This is the closest of the stages. Yes.
Source
إنكار المنكر — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.