The ruling on hearing the call of Allah other than Musa
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
The Shaykh informed us, may Allah guide you. You mentioned that there is a distinction between the call (nida') and the secret conversation (najwah). Has it been reported that anyone other than Musa heard the call of Allah?
Answer:
Allah knows best. The important point is that Musa heard the call of Allah. As for whether anyone else heard it, Allah knows best; we do not know about this. Was there anyone with Musa when He called them? No, there was no one with him, because he was traveling in the desert. So who can prove that there was anyone in that place other than Musa?
The Shaykh informed us, may Allah guide you. You mentioned that there is a distinction between the call (nida') and the secret conversation (najwah). Has it been reported that anyone other than Musa heard the call of Allah?
Answer:
Allah knows best. The important point is that Musa heard the call of Allah. As for whether anyone else heard it, Allah knows best; we do not know about this. Was there anyone with Musa when He called them? No, there was no one with him, because he was traveling in the desert. So who can prove that there was anyone in that place other than Musa?
Source
نداء الله لموسى عليه السلام — alfawzan.live
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.