The Methodology of the Companions Toward Unjust Rulers and the Uprisings of al-Husayn and Ibn al-Zubayr
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner:
He says: May Allah reward you. What is your view of those who say that the Companions and the Salaf had two methodologies toward unjust and oppressive rulers: the first is patience, and the second is rising up against oppressive rulers? They cite the uprisings of al-Husayn and Ibn al-Zubayr (may Allah be pleased with them all), and those who rose up on the Day of al-Hurr against Yazid, claiming that dozens of Companions were with them?
The Shaykh:
The Companions followed the methodology of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) and did not rise up against unjust rulers. This was their consensus, or that of the majority of them. As for the fact that some individuals among them exercised independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) and erred in it, it is possible for individuals to make errors in their ijtihad. What happened to some of them falls under this category: these were errors in their ijtihad. They receive reward for it and are excused by Allah (Glorified and Exalted is He), but they are not to be followed in this, and their actions are not to be cited as evidence, for their actions do not serve as valid proof. Yes.
The questioner:
He says: May Allah preserve you. What is your guidance for one who shaves his beard, or shortens it, or trims it, especially if it is a mouse-trap beard?
The Shaykh:
What did these actions reveal about their impact on the Muslims? What did the uprising of Ibn al-Zubayr reveal? Although Ibn al-Zubayr did not rise up against an established ruler, he wanted to take up the matter when the situation arose; he did not rise up against an established imam, God forbid. As for al-Hurr, yes, they rose up against Yazid based on their own ijtihad. What was the result? The result was great harm to the Muslims; no benefit or good outcome came to the Muslims. Yes.
He says: May Allah reward you. What is your view of those who say that the Companions and the Salaf had two methodologies toward unjust and oppressive rulers: the first is patience, and the second is rising up against oppressive rulers? They cite the uprisings of al-Husayn and Ibn al-Zubayr (may Allah be pleased with them all), and those who rose up on the Day of al-Hurr against Yazid, claiming that dozens of Companions were with them?
The Shaykh:
The Companions followed the methodology of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) and did not rise up against unjust rulers. This was their consensus, or that of the majority of them. As for the fact that some individuals among them exercised independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) and erred in it, it is possible for individuals to make errors in their ijtihad. What happened to some of them falls under this category: these were errors in their ijtihad. They receive reward for it and are excused by Allah (Glorified and Exalted is He), but they are not to be followed in this, and their actions are not to be cited as evidence, for their actions do not serve as valid proof. Yes.
The questioner:
He says: May Allah preserve you. What is your guidance for one who shaves his beard, or shortens it, or trims it, especially if it is a mouse-trap beard?
The Shaykh:
What did these actions reveal about their impact on the Muslims? What did the uprising of Ibn al-Zubayr reveal? Although Ibn al-Zubayr did not rise up against an established ruler, he wanted to take up the matter when the situation arose; he did not rise up against an established imam, God forbid. As for al-Hurr, yes, they rose up against Yazid based on their own ijtihad. What was the result? The result was great harm to the Muslims; no benefit or good outcome came to the Muslims. Yes.
Source
نعمــة الأمـن — alfawzan.live (39:55)
